portland independent media center  
images audio video
newswire article commentary united states

actions & protests

Rethinking the Peace Movement

March 20 - a day to change tactics.
Rethinking the Peace Movement

By Rosemarie Jackowski
March 20 is a day of historical importance. On March 20, 2003 there were world-wide protests against US military aggression. Millions of activists around the world participated. Some of the protests were inspired by US plans for "Shock and Awe". "Shock and Awe" was promised by the US government to be one of the most destructive military campaigns in history. In addition the US was at the same time threatening the use of nuclear weapons.

Historical perspective is needed. It has to be remembered that the US had been bombing Iraq since 1991. The bombing was a prelude to 9/11. 9/11 was Blowback - a predictable response to the many years of bombing by the US. Two other reasons for the 9/11 attack were the US policy against the Palestinians, and the location of US bases in Saudi Arabia.

Many peace activists have been protesting since 1991. Many continue to protest and plans are underway for demonstrations on March 20, 2010.

How effective have the protests been? Since 1991, the killing has continued. Civilians continue to die. The US killing machine has become even more deadly. The Pentagon continues to have access to unlimited funding. Private contractors and advancing technology add to the problem. The war is often engineered and managed from military bases within the US. Drones controlled from bases close to home provide an added level of comfort for the troops who can now go home for supper with the wife and kids. Killing has become as easy as going to the office - just another 9 to 5 job.

Meantime, the protesters have not changed their tactics. It is time to re-think the peace movement. Voting does not work because the US has no opposition party with enough power to bring peace. Protesting does not work. Singing songs, lighting candles, and peace vigils have not saved one human life. Innocent children and other civilians continue to die.

The way to achieve peace alludes all of us. Boycotts would be effective if enough people participated. That is not likely.

Pro-government propaganda from the media is a big part of the problem. The failure of the educational system is also part of the problem. Think of how much different things would be if Howard Zinn's "People's History of the United States" was the required text book in every classroom. That is a taxpayer friendly change that would cost nothing.

In the meantime, there is no light at the end of the tunnel.

On March 20, 2003, I was one of the millions who participated in a peaceful protest against the war. I was one of 12 in Bennington, Vermont who was arrested, incarcerated, handcuffed, booked, fingerprinted, and photographed. I alone was tried and convicted. Courtroom procedure allows the condemned the Right of Allocution at the time of Sentencing. This was the first time that I was allowed to speak freely and openly to the court. My Courtroom speech was delivered with passion. The passion remains today - but all hope has been abandoned.

Below are my words, as I spoke them, to Judge David Suntag, in Vermont District Court on October 7, 2004.

A Courtroom Speech

Your Honor, I would like to express my gratitude to you, the Prosecutor Mr. McManus, the members of the Bennington Police Department, to my family, especially Christine, to all those who support me, and especially to Mr. Saltonstall.

It is my profound respect for the Rule of Law that brought me to the 4 corners on March 20, 2003. At the precise moment of my arrest, the federal government of the United States was bombing civilians. The bombing of civilians is a violation of international law, a violation of U.S. treaties, a crime against humanity, and a war crime. Now that same government is sitting in judgment of many who have protested the war. Last week, in a court in Philadelphia, Lillian Willoughby, an 89-year-old deaf woman, in a wheelchair, was sentenced to prison. She had participated in a peaceful protest. Also in Philadelphia, Andrea Ferich, a 22 year old, was sentenced and she has just spent a week in solitary confinement. She also had participated in a peaceful protest. I have just been told that Michael Berg, father of Nick Berg, was arrested in a peaceful protest on Saturday, in Washington. All over this country, hundreds of those who have peacefully protested the war, are now condemned by the government. The way that this country is headed, eventually, all people of peace will be behind bars. I am in solidarity with them and all others who have resisted the government in the past, or will do so in the future.

Your Honor, it is with deep respect that I voice some concerns. How can it be that a nation, that is itself in violation of the law, can then hope to impose the rule of law on its citizens? I believe that either the rule of law applies to everyone, or else it applies to no one. Even a nation as powerful as the United States, can not have it both ways. The fact that the government of the U.S. is in violation of the law, is a fact that has been documented by many around the world. William Blum, one of the world's leading historians, and also former member of the US State Department, has authored several books on the topic - even naming one of his books about US foreign policy, Rogue State.

I have here a copy of the Indictment of 19 charges against members of the government as compiled by former US Attorney General Ramsey Clark. [I held the documents up for all to see.] Also, here is a statement from a group of US law professors. The statement is entitled "US Lawyers Warn Bush on War Crimes." Also, here is a report from an international human rights organization that is accredited by the United Nations. This report documents extensive US war crimes in Iraq. This is just a small sample of information that is easily available. Can all of these experts be wrong? Also, I have here an Associated Press report that was released shortly before my arrest, stating that the US was threatening to use nuclear weapons. That, too, is a war crime.

Your Honor, I believe that our government will not regain its legal and moral authority until it gives up its life of International Crime, and in the words of William Blum, is no longer a rogue state. It is important to say here, that the war in Iraq is not the first violation of human rights and International Law by the US. The abuse of people, people just like you and me, started back in 1492 and has been a consistent pattern ever since. Talk to some Native Americans, especially now that Columbus Day is upon us. Talk to our black brothers and sisters. Talk to the people of Diego Garcia or Panama or Hiroshima or Cuba...the list is endless.

As individual citizens, we all have rights and responsibilities. I believe that it is the responsibility of all citizens to resist any government, anywhere, anytime, when that government is slaughtering civilians. I, and many other protesters that I know, would gladly spend the rest of our lives in prison, if only the US would stop bombing civilians.

I have always been opposed to any form of violence. Seeing the photographs of the bombed Iraqi children has changed my life and strengthened my commitment to working for justice for those children. I do not understand how anyone can stand by silently, while knowing that civilians are being bombed. If what I, and the many thousands of others who protested the war, did, was wrong - what then would be the right thing to do? If you saw a child being beaten up and murdered on Main Street by a gang of thugs, should you write a letter to the editor or call your congressman or write a book on how adults should interact with children? Of course not. When children are being killed, immediate, direct, and powerful intervention is called for. What the other protesters and I did should be criticized in only one area. We all did too little. To all of the people of Iraq, I would like to say, "I am sorry. I will try to do better in the future."

I pray for the day when factory workers join with farmers, and police officers join with poets, and judges join with veterans in protesting the illegal acts of our government. Now is a time in history when silence is the greatest of all crimes.

What happens to me here today is not important. Since the day of my arrest, more than 13,000 Iraqi civilians, many of them children, have been killed. That IS important.

Rosemarie Jackowski is an advocacy journalist living in the USA.  dissent@sover.net

Onward 16.Feb.2010 09:27

Den Mark, Vancouver WA

There are many reasons why the peace movement has not accomplished much. Major reasons are not corporate power & consequent government corruption, tho those are factors, obviously. Major reason why this country causes so much suffering in the world is that most U.S. citizens do not care. The People allow U.S. aggression to happen.

"Protest doesn't work"? True, when only 1% of the public joins in. Protest works in Europe, because people get into the streets. And, of course, protest alone cannot work.

John & Jane Doe love to hear how great they are, how good they are, even tho it's a lie. This nation is built on Big Lies. Most nations are, but this nation has weapons to launch huge aggressions based on American mythology. Obama's recent SOTU speech again stroked that mythology, claiming how great a nation we are.

Americans are stupid & selfish. Humans as a whole are stupid & selfish. I'd say that we are animals, after all, but wolves & elephants & dolpins & bonobos are not stupid & selfish. So we don't measure up even to some animals.

After half a century of working for progressive ideals, i'm tired, but i refuse to give in, refuse to shut up, refuse to go away, refuse to be part of the majority that does not care. If i continue to see my shadow, the Light has my back!


And . . . 16.Feb.2010 09:35

Den Mark

Thank you for having given that speech & for sharing it with us today. Excellent!

"This nation is built on Big Lies." 16.Feb.2010 10:16

so true!

You hit the nail on the head there Den Mark. Rethink indeed. Truth is never convenient in this country. It stands in the way of our military and hegemonic so-called "progress". War is always based on lies. Peace can only be achieved with truth. Truth is the first casualty of war. Unplug the war machine- see you in the streets!

"Now is a time in history when silence is the greatest of all crimes." So true. Thanks for the article Rosemarie.

Bon Courage.... 16.Feb.2010 13:12

"Take heart," as the French would say

I've been really depressed about the state of any social change movements lately. The economy and the lack of jobs seem to be the straw that broke the camel's back, making it such that even activists are having a hard time getting themselves motivated to keep going. We need to remember that we are all organizers and that we are all activists, able to repair a broken system.
These are all statements from other people, some more famous than others, but I try to keep these in mind:
"Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful, committed citizens can change the world. Indeed, it is the only that that ever has." Margaret Meade
and, even more radically and individualistically,
"To open the Way, a cultural breakthrough need not involve masses of people but must be done decisively by someone." Jim Corbett, Quaker and one of the prime organizers of the first Sanctuary Movement.
I also try to take heed of the warning issued in the BETTER WORLD HANDBOOK, which compares the cycle of cynicism to the cycle of hope.
1. Finding out about a problem.
2. Wanting to do something to help.
3. Not seeing how you can help.
4. Not doing anything about it.
5. Feeling sad, powerless and angry.
6. Deciding that nothing can be done.
7. Begin shutting down.
8. Wanting to know less about problems.
Repeat till apathy results.
1. Taking personal responsibility for being a good person.
2. Creating a vision of a better world based on your values.
3. Seeking out quality information about the world's problems.
4. Discovering practical options for action.
5. Acting in line with your values.
Repeat till a better world results.
The BETTER WORLD HANDBOOK is available for borrowing through the Multnomah County Library System.
Part of effective movement building might include getting people to commit to a cycle of hope and helping people organize from where they are, rather than from where we want them to be. "Stupid" Americans may need redirection and the redirection probably needs to come from those of us -- whether small groups of thoughtful, committed citizens or individuals acting decisively -- who inspire by our example.