portland independent media center  
images audio video
newswire article reporting portland metro

actions & protests | police / legal

Grannies on Trial: “Substantial Inconvenience to United States?

On Tuesday, December 11, Multnomah County Judge Richard Baldwin and a jury of six heard the State's case and a response from three of five defendants in the trial of five grandparents charged with "unlawfully and knowingly causing substantial inconvenience to the United States." The case stems from a silent vigil held by the Surge Protection Brigade, also know as the Seriously Pissed Off Grannies, on Good Friday, April 6, at the US Army and Marine recruiting center on NE Broadway. The trial will resume on Wednesday, December 12, in Courtroom 716 at 9:00 AM in the Multnomah County Courthouse, 1021 SW 4th.
Preparing for Trial
Preparing for Trial
District Attorney Seth Stuart contends that the defendants intended to "substantially inconvenience" the US military by disrupting recruiting at the Broadway office. Defendant Clyde Chamberlain, a father and grandfather, said "I was not concerned with inconvenience to the US Military. I was concerned by the considerable inconvenience our government and military have caused to the hundreds of thousands of Iraqi citizens who have lost their lives, and to our soldiers who have died fighting an illegal and immoral war."

The defendants pled "not guilty" to charges of criminal mischief in the third degree because they believe their actions constituted a symbolic act of political speech at a government office and resulted in no damage to the property. All three of the defendants heard today said that their intention was to send a political message to our country that "war is wrong." Sara Graham, a 67 year old grandmother, testified that the group wanted to make a statement on Good Friday because that is the day the government killed Jesus Christ, and through the war in Iraq our government is killing innocent civilians." The group carefully planned the event they called "Blood and Roses" to maximize the symbolic statement and minimize any damage. During the silent vigil the group placed fake "blood" made of corn syrup, dishwashing liquid, and red food coloring on the sidewalk and red handprints on the windows of the Army/Marine Recruiting office at 1371 NE Broadway. Ann Huntwork testified "we used red tempera paint to make the handprints because it washes off easily. Every mother knows that."

The State tried to establish that the vigil had inflicted substantial property damage to the US Army and Marine Recruiting Centers. But witnesses Bradford Schultz and Morris Levenspiel the Regional and local property managers for the Military and the building owner could not produce a repair bill that itemized the cost for cleaning the red handprints off of the windows. The documentation they brought was ruled inadmissible by Judge Baldwin because it did not directly state repair costs for damage alleged from the April 6 vigil.

Monday Judge Baldwin projected that the case would go to the jury for decision by Thursday afternoon.


PS Bonnie Tinker was not arrested at the Blood and Roses vigil on Good Friday, April 6, at the Recruiting office. She is not facing charges in this case or any case related to April 6.

They left the prints up for weeks!! 12.Dec.2007 07:11

Styve

The handprints were left on the windows of the recruiting center for several weeks after, if not over a month. That evidence would speak to the issue that the "vandalism" was inconsequential and tolerable.

PPRC people could testify to that, because we saw the prints right after 4/6 and a month later, during the Saturday anti-recruitment protest.

Styve

wed info 12.Dec.2007 14:28

Ben Waiting

wednesday trial info request

Show Trial 12.Dec.2007 16:01

Harry Kershner

The fact that these pacifistic Christians can be put on trial for criminality because they put easily removable poster paint on a window is a message to the rest of us.

If they are convicted of this idiotic charge, it is one more nail in the coffin of U.S. civil liberties, and that is what this trial is really about. Stalin and Hitler would be proud.

Thank you Grannies 12.Dec.2007 16:09

Marlena Gangi

And Bonnie for great reporting. Wish I could make the trial, with you in spirit. Adelante!!

today in court 12.Dec.2007 17:05

IneedMorePatience

Are there any updates from Wednesday court hearing available

Wed morning 12.Dec.2007 18:05

medic

I was there to watch for a few hours this morning and just wanted to say it was a great kick. Seeing these grannies take the stand was awesome- they are humorous and NEVER let go of their desire to spread love and win people over with their words. There were at least 2 indy-type reporters there and I assume they'll post full details, but I'll share what I saw.

Both of the grannies who testified today refused to allow the prosecutor to change their words, such as when he repeatedly asked one of them, "You say you'd do anything to stop wars. Does that mean you'd do anything to stop someone from joining the military?" The granny replied, "Stop implies impede. I'd rather educate the person so they can make their own informed decision as to joining up or not." The prosecutor looked confused and a cycle of him asking the same question and the granny giving the same answer, at least four times over, ensued until finally one of the defense lawyers objected and the judge intervened.

Some other goodies from today:
Attorney: "Could the poster paint cause damage to a window?" Granny: "Well, if you froze it and threw it at the window, I guess. But I couldn't even throw it that hard, you'd have to get Clyde to do it."

When the prosecutor apolizied for the poor quality photos used to show the "damage," saying, "Our printers just aren't very good," the Granny replied, "Well, maybe if our country wasn't at war, we could afford better printers in your office."

Overall, I'd say watching any activist trial is a fun and worthwhile activity, but watching 5 SPOGs together was just a kick. I'll be watching here for further updates!

update absorbed 12.Dec.2007 18:23

IneedMorePatience

right on

thanks (medic)


Go Granny<s> Go

wow!!

Its the first time today I noticed I was smiling !!!

Arrest Bush and Cheney for Trail in the World Court 13.Dec.2007 01:50

Fr. Jim Waters, Franciscan Priest

Friends,

We've seen trials and indictments against the gov't officials in the Balkans and the Sudan not to mention other nations. While we call for Bush and Cheney to be held accountable for crimes against humanity I do not see the Left calling for the arrest against the Communist Gov't of China.. who now kill Christians, and anyone who is standing for Human Rights to harvest their organs..etc. We must finally stand as World Citizens.... we must form a Peace Army of millions to take over the US Gov't..by force of the will of the people. In fact the USA was founded on the belief put forth by our founding citizens..! We must form into an army of people to take over and stop all action in Washington, DC. go to the White House. .march past the Secret Service and military to take into custody.. then to take Cheney and Bush to the Hague to place both terrorists and global criminals on trial for mass murder, for lying to create a war that continues to kill and maim thousands upon thousands. The time is now.. Under Bush the nation is racing toward using Tactical Nukes in Iran by Spring time.

The terrorist military of the USA .. the terrorist agents of death .. our own Portland Police, the Secret Service and FBI will fight.. and kill thousands of us. .I intend on being on the fronline to lay down my life to once and for all Halt American Terror on the World. Those standing in our way .. in the way of the American People will be dealt with and placed in holding camps till Bush and Cheney are tried, convicted and sentenced for Execution for Crimes against Humanity. Bush had Saddahm hung.. so must he face the same punnishment. .should the world court so dictate. This is not up to us.. we can only do what a moral peacefull army of citizens to.. hand these creators of terrorism for trial.

I intend on contacting any and all groups the world over to find how we can form a citizens army to arrest Bush and Cheney.. to force the Congress to step down .. to force the police agencies to also ceease their acts against citizens of our cities. I also intend on placing on trial for crimes against humanity a large number of Terrorist Portland Cops.. and Gov't leaders. The time is now to take a stand .. even if many of must die.

I am willing to die for this cause. How many are willing to step forward to stop this inane freaky protesting by Portland's weird fools.. this is not a war of fools.. these people have never seen war. never seen the mass graves .. I have .. this is an effort that must be met by all Americans.. let them come arrest me with their SWAT Teams. .I will fight for my rights as a citizen.. they will not take me quietly .. let them set forth the dogs of war!

Fr. Jim Waters, FBS

A Win for Democracy And Peace 14.Dec.2007 02:21

Joe Anybody Ben Waiting

Grannies win by the Jury saying "not guilty"
(side-note) The Judge still fines them 100 each
Stay tuned for more on that (?)
Also I should have their press release <video> posted right here on Indy Media by Friday 12/14 evening

Go Grannies!
organizing
organizing
At the conference
At the conference
Corporate Press
Corporate Press