portland independent media center  
images audio video
newswire article reposts global

anti-racism | imperialism & war

Palestine: THE ONE STATE DECLARATION

November 29 marked the 60th anniversary of the UN resolution to partition Palestine.
THE ONE STATE DECLARATION

The Electronic Intifada, 29 November 2007
 http://electronicintifada.net/v2/article9134.shtml

For decades, efforts to bring about a two-state solution in historic
Palestine have failed to provide justice and peace for the
Palestinian and Israeli Jewish peoples, or to offer a genuine
process leading towards them.

The two-state solution ignores the physical and political realities
on the ground, and presumes a false parity in power and moral claims
between a colonized and occupied people on the one hand and a
colonizing state and military occupier on the other. It is
predicated on the unjust premise that peace can be achieved by
granting limited national rights to Palestinians living in the areas
occupied in 1967, while denying the rights of Palestinians inside
the 1948 borders and in the Diaspora. Thus, the two-state solution
condemns Palestinian citizens of Israel to permanent second-class
status within their homeland, in a racist state that denies their
rights by enacting laws that privilege Jews constitutionally,
legally, politically, socially and culturally. Moreover, the
two-state solution denies Palestinian refugees their internationally
recognized right of return.

The two-state solution entrenches and formalizes a policy of unequal
separation on a land that has become ever more integrated
territorially and economically. All the international efforts to
implement a two-state solution cannot conceal the fact that a
Palestinian state is not viable, and that Palestinian and Israeli
Jewish independence in separate states cannot resolve fundamental
injustices, the acknowledgment and redress of which are at the core
of any just solution.

In light of these stark realities, we affirm our commitment to a
democratic solution that will offer a just, and thus enduring, peace
in a single state based on the following principles:

- The historic land of Palestine belongs to all who live in it and
to those who were expelled or exiled from it since 1948, regardless
of religion, ethnicity, national origin or current citizenship
status;

-Any system of government must be founded on the principle of
equality in civil, political, social and cultural rights for all
citizens. Power must be exercised with rigorous impartiality on
behalf of all people in the diversity of their identities;

- There must be just redress for the devastating effects of decades
of Zionist colonization in the pre- and post-state period, including
the abrogation of all laws, and ending all policies, practices and
systems of military and civil control that oppress and discriminate
on the basis of ethnicity, religion or national origin;

-The recognition of the diverse character of the society,
encompassing distinct religious, linguistic and cultural traditions,
and national experiences;

-The creation of a non-sectarian state that does not privilege the
rights of one ethnic or religious group over another and that
respects the separation of state from all organized religion;

-The implementation of the Right of Return for Palestinian refugees
in accordance with UN Resolution 194 is a fundamental requirement
for justice, and a benchmark of the respect for equality.

-The creation of a transparent and nondiscriminatory immigration
policy;

- The recognition of the historic connections between the diverse
communities inside the new, democratic state and their respective
fellow communities outside;

-In articulating the specific contours of such a solution, those who
have been historically excluded from decision-making -- especially
the Palestinian Diaspora and its refugees, and Palestinians inside
Israel -- must play a central role;

-The establishment of legal and institutional frameworks for justice
and reconciliation.

The struggle for justice and liberation must be accompanied by a
clear, compelling and moral vision of the destination - a solution
in which all people who share a belief in equality can see a future
for themselves and others. We call for the widest possible
discussion, research and action to advance a unitary, democratic
solution and bring it to fruition.

Madrid and London, 2007

Signed:

Ali Abunimah
Naseer Aruri
Omar Barghouti
Oren Ben-Dor
George Bisharat
Haim Bresheeth
Jonathan Cook
Ghazi Falah
Leila Farsakh
Islah Jad
Joseph Massad
Ilan Pappe
Carlos Prieto del Campo
Nadim Rouhana
The London One State Group

Jews Are Not a Race, Only a Religion 01.Dec.2007 17:09

Realist

Jews are no more a race than Christians, or Moslems are. Judahism is a religion, and the Zionist idea that Jews are a race, like Arabs, Asians, Blacks, and Whites, are each a race is as ridiculous as saying that Catholics are a race, and therefore should be able to occupy a country, and deport, segregate, descriminate against, imprison and murder that country's native population, just as Jews have done to the Palestinian People. Isreal should be disolved and Palestine restored.

actually 01.Dec.2007 20:29

it's really a question of culture.

seeing as this article is old, i doubt anyone would read this. but, whereas catholics cannot really claim an ethnicity, jews can. we are ethnically, or culturally jewish.

To explain that 02.Dec.2007 05:10

Mike Novack stepbystpefarm <a> mtdata.com

"Realist", while this is not common, especially among the large tribes, the Jews are a multi-racial, multi-cultural tribe with a tribal religion.

Judaism IS different from Catholicism (or most religions) in that sense. It is simply impossible to become Jewish without joining the tribe (part of the ceremony is "adoption"; converts are technically children of Abraham and Sarah). That's not uncommon in the case of tribes with a tribal religion. The only reason not obvious is all the rest of the examples are small tribes. And as already noted, perhaps most tribes don't have a tribal religion in the sense the Jews do.

Otherwise, the tribe is matrilineal. If your mother is Jewish, you are UNLESS you take postive action to leave the tribe/religion (passively being non-observant doesn't count; declaring atheism doesn't count -- have to actually become "something else").

Not Actually 02.Dec.2007 12:31

Realist

"It's really a question of culture. Seeing as this article is old, I doubt anyone would read this. But, whereas Catholics cannot really claim an ethnicity, Jews can. We are ethnically, or culturally Jewish.

This is not accurate.

From Wikipedia:

"An ethnic group or ethnicity is a population of human beings whose members identify with each other, usually on the basis of a presumed common genealogy or ancestry."

Jews are members of a religion hailing from countries all over the world. Jews do not share a common genealogy or ancestry, although Zionists claim that Jews are Semitic, this is false, they are Russian, German, French, even Somali; many non-Jewish peoples of Arab ancestry from the Middle East are of Semitic ancestry. Again, Jews are members of a religion, not a race.

From Wikipedia:

"Ethnicity is also defined from the recognition by others as a distinct group and by common cultural, linguistic, religious, behavioral or biological traits."

Jews around the world do not share a common language, (Hebrew is not a common language among Jews) or any common biological traits, so Jews are not linguistically or biologically an ethnic group. Jews do share common cultural and behavioral traits because they are members of a religion; a religion that any person anywhere might convert to I might add. So in that regard, Catholics can also claim to be ethnically, or culturally Catholic; following that criteria for ethnicity, stamp collectors could claim to be ethnically, or culturally stamp collectors because they too share a behavioral trait. So again, we see how ridiculous any claim that Jews are a legitimate ethnic, or cultural group is. Jews have as much claim to being an ethnic culture as do Roller Derby fans and Britney Spears groupies. Jews are members of a religion, not a race; and if you do not actively practice Judaism as a religious faith, then I hate to break it to you, but you're not a Jew. You might be considered a Zionist though. Isreal should be disolved, and Zionist occupation "settlers" should be deported, and Palestine restored to its people.

From Wikipedia:

"The sociologist Max Weber once remarked, "The whole conception of ethnic groups is so complex and so vague that it might be good to abandon it altogether."

Jews Exist Because of Anti-Semitism 02.Dec.2007 15:51

anarchosemite

This imbecilic tirade about what Jews are and are not is eblematic of Portland bigotry. Jews are inter-marrying at increasing rates in America. We would no longer exist if people like Realist didn't find us to be such valuable scapegoats.

Show Me 03.Dec.2007 02:14

nomad

. . . "valuable scapegoats"?

Where does "Realist" seek to assign blame for the deeds of others on Jews? Where does she cast blame for shortcomings or failure on an innocent or only partly responsible group, in this case, for "anarchosemite", Jews?

It looks more to me like an examination of the semantics, of definition of the terms "race", "ethnicity", etc. and how those terms are or might be applied and claimed.

Is a critique (call it "imbecilic tirade" if you want) of the premises of Zionism antisemitic?