author: The Akha Heritage Foundation posts this article

e-mail:
akhalife@gmail.com
Destruction of Akha Culture, Rotary International and CGT Mission Thailand
An Open Letter To Trevi Albin of Rotary International:
Trevi Albin:
If the four points of Rotary's statement of ethics, the "4-way test," are to be standards that bind all Rotarians in all their activities carried out in the name of their organization, we believe you, Trevi Albin, have failed to live up to those standards, and therefore reflect very poorly on the ability of Rotary as an organization to uphold it's professed standards. Your support of the efforts of "Children of the Golden Triangle" in their conversion of traditional Akha to Christianity, and your failure to fully inform your audience of the dynamics of the situation facing the Akha in Thailand, are absolutely inexcusable in light of the pledge you presumably took to deal honestly with these questions:
"1) Is it the TRUTH?
2) Is it FAIR to all concerned?
3) Will it build GOODWILL and BETTER FRIENDSHIPS?
4)Will it be BENEFICIAL to all concerned?"
You are the person at Rotary who is primarily responsible for failing to serve the best interests of the traditional Akha people, since you do take full responsibility for the images of and information about the Akha which Rotary has published.
You have failed to be fair to and truthful about traditional Akha in your reporting. You are certainly not creating goodwill by contributing to the ethnocide of the Akha and the total elimination of their traditions by CGT missionaries. Your actions are to the detriment of a people, not beneficial to them.
It seems to us that the people your work benefits most are the missionaries whose salaries get paid by good-hearted donors (upon whose generosity your salary also presumably depends). Of course, these projects are also beneficial in the sense that they can salve the guilty consciences of some of the more priveleged donors who could care less what their money is going to support (Yes, donors do also share responsibility for finding out what exactly they are funding). But we have a hard time seeing how your work will in any way prevent Akha traditions from being lost, and Akha communities from being shattered. In fact, we very much believe that you contribute to that process.
We understand that there are many well-intentioned people at Rotary, and we don't want to place all the blame on them for supporting bad projects if they are supporting those projects only because they have incomplete information. We feel that you, Trevi Albin, are responsible for providing all relevant background to the sponsors of the projects you cover, and if you haven't heard of missionaries bribing Akha parents and pressuring them to give their children up to the care of orphanages, we suggest you do some further research (Or would you not see anything wrong with that?...) Akha.org is a good place to start learning, but the missionaries' websites themselves will tell you a lot you might prefer to gloss over, if you care to dig deep enough.
Until you give a more considerate treatment to the situation of the traditional Akha people, we will continue to see you, and unfortunately the whole organization you represent, as utterly irresponsible in your coverage and as negligent and contemptuous in your attitude and behavior toward non-Christian Akha.
|