portland independent media center  
images audio video
newswire article reposts global

economic justice | human & civil rights

Alternative Social Forum in Venezuela

An Alternative Social Forum, or ASF, set up in protest against the World Social Forum is quietly taking place in Caracas now. One of its organisers, Esteban Mejiaz said, "We have created a space outside the forum where a more critical debate about Venezuela can take place."
Small and Earnest Alternative Social Forum in Venezuela
Friday, Jan 27, 2006

By: Alex Holland - Venezuelanalysis.com

ASF meeting in a supporters' home.
ASF meeting in a supporters' home.
Credit: Alex Holland

Caracas, Venezuela, 26 January 2006—An Alternative Social Forum, or ASF, set up in protest against the World Social Forum is quietly taking place in Caracas now. One of its organisers, Esteban Mejiaz said, "We have created a space outside the forum where a more critical debate about Venezuela can take place."

The ASF cannot compare for size or attendance to the World Social Forum, or WSF. The ASF is hosting 20 events. These are being held in a few rooms at the Venezuelan Central University and a small house in the Caracas neighbourhood of Los Simbolos.

In contrast, the World Social Forum has 2,200 events. Many huge public buildings in Caracas are being used to host these. At least 60,000 people are attending. As many as 100,000 are expected by the end.

Mejiaz could not say how many people are attending the ASF, "Unlike the WSF there is no registration for our event." It is clear, though, not many are taking part in the ASF. Less than 30 people were present in its main site yesterday.

Venezuelans from the anarchist group CRA (Commission for Anarchist Relations) organized the rival forum. They said it was not possible to have a truly free debate with the Venezuelan government spending so much money on the event.

The CRA said the Social Forums in Brazil had suffered from the same problem. They feel no government should sponsor an event like the WSF. The CRA think there is corruption in the Venezuelan government but made clear that they are not against all of its policies.

Mejiaz said, "there are a lot of opportunities for the people in Venezuela now because of the free healthcare and education." The anarchist also said, "the greatest threat to the left in Venezuela is the US and its allies in this country, not Chavez."

Most of the non-Venezuelans attending the ASF also attended the WSF. Nick Cooper from Texas in the USA said, "I think its good to have variety, spaces where everyone can be comfortable."

Cooper did have some criticisms of the WSF too. The North American said, "I do think that some governments host the WSF to show off their left wing credentials. In Brazil especially I think this was compensating for a lack of something at home."

The CRA said they did not feel it was worth having events at the WSF at the same time as the ASF. Mejiaz said, "a lot of the people at the WSF are revolutionary tourists. They want to buy a T-shirt, say they've done something and then go home."

 http://www.venezuelanalysis.com/news.php?newsno=1879

homepage: homepage: http://www.venezuelanalysis.com/news.php?newsno=1879

And the ASF is important because?... 30.Jan.2006 07:35

angry gringo

This article says exactly NOTHING about why the ASF was held. I can't really see a reason, except to say that you're doing something "more pure" than the supposedly "tainted" WSF. Whatever.

What is more important?: Stopping US genocidal policies around the world and creating an alternative to neo-liberal economic policies that destroy the environment, autonomy, and human dignity OR screaming about an imagined "freedom" that only comes with the desire to preserve middle-class wealth. Anarchists think they are so pure, but very few REALLY put themselves on the line when it comes to fighting oppression. (My hat's off to those who really do.)

suspicions allayed 31.Jan.2006 22:24

g.d. dem

This ASF thing first came to my attention because when searching the net for something on "WSF Caracas", the few and only U.S. media coverage featured the ASF and its criticism of the Chavez government and almost nothing else. That, along with some anti-Fidel stuff posted a while back by Cuban "anarchists", (and calling for unilateral disarmament by the Cuban people!), made me very suspicious of the ASF.

But now we get here a better report on the ASF:

< Mejiaz said, "there are a lot of opportunities for the people in Venezuela now because of the free healthcare and education." The anarchist also said, "the greatest threat to the left in Venezuela is the US and its allies in this country, not Chavez."

< Most of the non-Venezuelans attending the ASF also attended the WSF.

< Mejiaz said, "a lot of the people at the WSF are revolutionary tourists. They want to buy a T-shirt, say they've done something and then go home."

You know, there's probably something to that!

Anyway, this isn't the anti-Chavez U.S.-inspired thing that the U.S. media was making it out to be.

That still doesn't explain... 01.Feb.2006 12:39

Gringo dos veces

a good reason to hold the ASF. If you don't like some of Chavez's policies, there's definitely space within the WSF to put on a workshop critiquing the govt. No lie.

And if we're in agreement about opposing imperialism and the like, where is the alternative to the way Chavez is doing it? The ASF did not put that forth.

I agree, sure, its not part of the right wing attack on Chavez, but its a very limp left wing critique that borders on whining.

They should've hung it up and drank more chicha instead.