portland independent media center  
images audio video
newswire article reposts united states

actions & protests | human & civil rights | police / legal

Arrested for Preaching: Freedom is not FREE

ACLU Defends Portales Street Preacher
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE:
Thursday, August 4th, 2005
CONTACT:
Peter Simonson, Executive Director, ACLU of New Mexico at 505-266-4622 or (cell) 505-620-0775
Portales--Some deft legal work by the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) of New Mexico succeeded in freeing street preacher Shawn Miller from the Roosevelt County jail yesterday.
Portales police arrested Miller for disorderly conduct on April 17th because allegedly he was yelling at passing cars. Miller maintains that he was merely "preaching the word of God."
ACLU Executive Director Peter Simonson said, "Mr. Miller has a guaranteed right to stand on a street corner and proclaim his faith in God to all who pass by. He wasn't harassing or intimidating anyone. He certainly should not have spent time under lock and key for such a minor incident."
The ACLU became involved after Miller's wife, Theresa, sent a letter requesting assistance. She and her two children had been with Miller on the day he was arrested. He was preaching in the lot of an abandoned gas station that is commonly used by street vendors. "I was preaching the word of God and not hurting anybody," said Miller.
The ACLU's defense of Miller produced an unlikely collaboration with the American Family Association, a group that is at times at odds with ACLU positions. Attorneys from both groups consulted with each other and Miller, working together to defend him on First Amendment grounds.
"Both organizations are highly principled in their philosophies and policy positions," said ACLU Staff Attorney George Bach. "Where those principles overlap, we are eager to collaborate."
Miller was released on bond and still faces charges of disorderly conduct, in addition to resisting arrest.
 link to www.aclu.org
And in two newspapers:
 link to www.clovis-news-nm.com
 link to www.pntonline.com
fine lines 11.Aug.2005 23:39

peace

I don't know about this guy, but some street preachers using the free speech provision definitely seem to enjoy harrassing and tormenting people, at pioneer square for example. The aclu has to do their job, we'd be the worse withought them, but certain particularly aggressive street preachers, or more commonly, bible thumpers deserve the burden of a very discerning eye for their use of the the first amendment.

bizarre bedfellows 12.Aug.2005 06:36

[unlike]

Aw...Those poor, poor oppressed christians. Will they never find a place of their own, a dominion to rule....Oh, wait.

Next they'll be hard at work standing up for the rights of 'marginalized' corporations.

Let's all try standing on street corners screaming what we believe at each other and see what happens.

Yep, we still live in a police state. 12.Aug.2005 11:55

Yo Mama

This is just yet another example of the police taking this too far, but when has that ever stopped them? They KILL people here in Portland over less.

You won't hear this on Faux News 12.Aug.2005 15:00

Andy

O'Reilly and Co. always jump on any opportunity to bash the ACLU for their supposed left-wing advocacy. But the ACLU fighting for a bible-thumping, Jesus-humping ass of their own? Oh no, that would destroy their picture of the ACLU that they've been trying to sell to their audience.

Make sure you keep these links for the next time a right-winger wants to smear the ACLU.

LOVE 21.Aug.2005 11:52

Shawn Miller sfmtlmnm2005@netscape.com

I spent 109 days in jail. I was with my wife and two children. We were having a quiet Bible Study in an abandoned gas station. I know that there are misguided Street Preachers (like Saul before he was Paul). I read that JESUS was a friend of the sinner. How can we win anyone if we are yelling at them? JESUS said the world is already condemned.

Why was I arrested? 24.Aug.2005 05:30

Shawn Miller sfmtlmnm2005@netscape.com

My wife, our two children, and I had been going for three months to this same abandoned gas station without any incident. We were simply having a quiet Bible study on Sunday morning. The bank across the street is closed. There are two churches (Baptist & Methodist) on opposite corners from us. There is a minimal amount of car traffic and no pedestrian traffic. We are NOT there to be heard. We are simply there trying to let our light shine. We are NOT yelling at anyone because there is no one around. Sure, cars pass and see us, but there is no way we are disturbing them since we are 15 feet away from the sidewalk. This police officer decided to pick on us that day for some unknown reason. Officer Smart, Officer Wilson, and an animal control officer were in the parking lot adjacent to us at about 9:45 and they stayed for about 20-30 minutes. Then they all left. A sheriff's deputy watched us for about five minutes a week before that day. Many police cars had driven by throughout the previous months WITHOUT incident. Officer Smart then came back at 11:05. I went over to him and extended my hand and said, "What is the problem, officer?" He said, "You need to tone it down." I said, "I am preaching to my family and we are not bothering anyone. This is free speech and you can not stop me." He said, "We have been getting phone calls about you pointing and yelling at cars." I said, "I was not yelling at cars and was not pointing and I was not bothering anyone. This is free speech and you can not stop me. If you have a problem with me being on this property, I will go to the sidewalk." He said, "I do not have a problem with you being here, you just need to tone it down." I said, "If you are going to arrest me, I am going to go to the sidewalk because it is public property." So I went to the sidewalk (for the first time). By this time, Officer Wilson arrived. Officer Smart looked at Officer Wilson as I was walking away to the sidewalk and they both shrugged. I was standing on the sidewalk looking at the officers. Officer Smart said, "Come back here." I did not want to get arrested for trespassing, so I stayed where I was. I said, "No, I am staying on the sidewalk because it is public property." He then came towards me. I have seen the TV show "COPS." I thought it best to get on my knees and put my hands in the air to show that I was not resisting arrest. At this time, a University police officer also drove up. So, there were three police cars at this abandoned gas station, obviously causing much attention and causing people to rubberneck. Officer Smart came and handcuffed me and took me to his car. I said, "There are drug dealers and bars in this town and people getting killed, but that's ok, I'll gladly be arrested for preaching the Gospel." When I got to his car, I asked, "Why am I being arrested?" He said, "For disorderly conduct and obstruction. You can not walk away from me if I am asking you questions."

Understanding 26.Aug.2005 13:53

Shawn Miller sfmtlmnm2005@netscape.com

Here is a list of disputable statements that Officer Smart made in his statement of probable cause when he arrested Shawn on April 17:
(1) Officer Smart states that at approximately 1105 hours he was dispatched to 2nd St. and Ave C in reference to a subject "yelling" at vehicles driving by:
--Officer Smart's statement does not mention anything about being at the self-pay gas station next to where we were earlier that morning; he doesn't state why he was there at that time: was he dispatched, or was he there out of his own choice?
--Was Officer Smart dispatched as a result of a 911 call? Is there a recording of the call or can a transcript of the conversation be obtained?

(2) Officer Smart states Shawn was "standing in the area":
--What area exactly was Shawn standing in?

(3) Officer Smart states Shawn appeared to be attempting to call out to vehicle occupants as the drove by:
--Shawn was facing Matthew, Michelle, and me as we sat in a semi-circle in our folding chairs facing him. The three of us had our backs to 2nd St. and Shawn was facing the street, but we were between him and the street. Officer Smart would have been able to see that Shawn was talking to us because he pulled into the abandoned gas station parking lot right next to where our chairs were positioned and where Shawn was standing. Officer Smart would have been able to see that we were interacting with Shawn as well as Shawn talking to us.

(4) Officer Smart states he attempted to advise him of his presence:
--How exactly was he attempting to advise Shawn of his presence? Shawn was aware of Officer Smart's presence; Shawn had walked over to Officer Smart's police car when Officer Smart got out of his car.
(5) Officer Smart states he repeatedly told Shawn to calm down and listen and Shawn continued to get louder with his objections each time Officer Smart tried to discuss the issue:
--What was the issue that Officer Smart was trying to discuss with Shawn?
--The only thing Shawn told Officer Smart was that he had the right to free speech and he had the right to preach out on the streets.
(6) Officer Smart states Shawn walked back to the curb:
--Shawn had never been at the curb to have walked back to it; Shawn has never stood on the curb during any of our street meetings.
(7) Officer Smart states that Shawn continued "yelling" out at vehicles:
--There were only two things Shawn said when he was standing on the curb and both statements were to Officer Smart:
1) He told Officer Smart he had the right to preach on the sidewalk because it was public property;
2) When Officer Smart told Shawn to come back to where he was, Shawn told Officer Smart that he would stay on the sidewalk because it was public property (in Officer Smart's statement, he doesn't even mention this part of the conversation with Shawn)

--Shawn did not yell anything out to the vehicles that were passing; his comments were only directed at Officer Smart.
(8) Officer Smart states that he once again advised Shawn to stop and at that point he got down on his knees and began waving his arms above his head:
--Shawn got on his knees and raised his hands over his head as soon as Officer Smart took a step toward him to let Officer Smart know he was not resisting him or anything. Shawn was not waving his hands over his head; and the only thing he said when he got to his knees was that he had the right to preach on the sidewalk.
(9) Officer Smart states that as Shawn's actions were disrupting the flow of traffic he advised Shawn if he did not stop he would arrest him and Shawn's reaction was "I don't have to listen to you":
--Officer Smart never told Shawn that if he didn't stop he would arrest him; Officer Smart just walked over to where Shawn was on the sidewalk, got out his handcuffs, and arrested him.
--As previously stated, the only thing Shawn said when he was on his knees was that he had the right to preach on the sidewalk.

Two other quick points concerning Officer Smart:
(1) Officer Smart did not read Shawn his Miranda Rights; you can see that on the arrest report and Shawn has stated that he was not read his rights.
(2) Officer Smart does not mention his conversation with me: after he arrested Shawn and put him in the back of his police car, Officer Smart handed me Shawn's keys and told me Shawn was being arrested for obstruction. He said when someone complains, he has to do something about it. I told Officer Smart that Shawn was not yelling at the passing cars; the four of us were simply having our bible study out here on the streets. Officer Smart then told me he had no problem with us practicing religion on the streets but people can't walk away from him when he's talking to them. From my standpoint, it appears that Officer Smart got mad that Shawn walked away from him to the curb. Shawn told him he was walking to the curb as he walked away, and Shawn walked to the curb so he wouldn't get in trouble for trespassing again since the trespassing charge in January was not yet cleared up. I did not tell this to Officer Smart at the time; I don't know if it would have helped if I had.
******************************************************************************************
This is from Teresa Miller.
Thank you,
Shawn Miller
912 S. Ave. A
Portales, NM 88130
505-356-6730

 sfmtlmnm2005@netscape.com

Charges Are Dropped 03.Nov.2005 11:30

Shawn Miller sfmtlmnm@yahoo.com

October 17, 2005
Dear Shawn,
Good news:
The D.A. issue a "nolle prosequi" in your case, which means she "will no further prosecute" it (you may hear it called a "NO LE PROS"). More informally, it is generally taken to mean that a district attorney either did not feel pursuing the case was in the interest of justice or that there wasn't enough there substantively to pursue it. Technically, they retain the right to re-charge you at some point, but that is highly unlikely in your situation.
I can fax you a copy of the document if you need - and will mail you one today.
At some point, I will take a look at the NM law to see when exactly, we can also request that your arrest record be expunged so that you are not dealing with even that in terms of background checks. But for now, you are currently free of all charges, pending trials, bail, etc.
I have various meetings this evening, but please give me a call tomorrow at work or let me know when a good time to call you is.
Best regards,
George Bach
Staff Attorney - ACLU of New Mexico
P.O. Box 566 Albuquerque, NM 87103-0566
(505) 243-0046 FAX: (505) 266-5916
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 link to 164.64.40.11
Data use is subject to NMSA 1978, Sec. 14-3-15.1(1995).
STATE VS. SHAWN MILLER
-- Case Detail --
Case #: M-44-MR-200500136
Current Judge: JANE A MARTIN
Case Status: CL FINAL CLOSED Status Date: 10/19/2005
Filing Date: 04/18/2005
Court: Portales Magistrate Court
-- Parties to this Case --
DEFENDANT D 1 MILLER SHAWN
Attorney(s): JOHN B BIGELOW
-- Register of Actions Activity --
Event Date Event Description P Type P Num Amt
01/26/2006 CAL: TRIAL JURY
Calendar Posting on 09-01-2005

12/16/2005 CAL: HEARING/MTN D 1
Calendar Posting on 09-01-2005
TO BE SET BEFORE 1/26/06.
09/08/2005 C :CONTINUED/RESET

12/07/2005 CAL: HEARING/MTN
Calendar Posting on 10-04-2005

10/19/2005 CLS: DIS NOLLE PROS BEF TRIAL D 1
FILED BY DONNA MOWRER DEPUTY DA

10/04/2005 NTC: OF HEARING D 1 0.00
9NT-00718 issued by 23 (6005) NTC: OF HEARING
MTN HRG SET FOR 12/7/05 AT 10:30 AM

10/03/2005 MISC ENTRY D 1
NEW ADDRESS GIVEN

09/08/2005 ORD: FOR CONTINUANCE D 1
APPROVED - TO BE SET BEFORE 1/26/06.

09/08/2005 MTN: FOR CONTINUANCE D 1
FILED BY DONNA MOWRER FOR 12/16/05 - HEARING IN DISTRICT
COURT PREVIOUSLY SET.

09/06/2005 MISC ENTRY D 1
NOTICE OF CHANGE OF ADDRESS FILED BY GEORGE BACH.

09/06/2005 WITNESS LIST RECVD D 1
FILED BY THE STATE - DONNA MOWRER.

09/01/2005 NTC: OF TRIAL (CRIMINAL) D 1
JT 1-26-06 @ 9:00 AM

09/01/2005 NTC: OF HEARING D 1
MTN HRG 12-16-05 @ 10:00 AM

08/31/2005 CAL: PRE-TRIAL CONFERENCE D 1
Calendar Posting on 08-09-2005
09/01/2005 HRD :HEARD

08/09/2005 NTC: CRIMINAL PRETRIAL CONFER D 1
8-31-05 @ 1:30 PM

08/04/2005 REMAND ORDER D 1
REMANDED BACK ON DEF'S UNOPPOSED MTN TO WITHDRAW REQUEST FOR
FORENSIC EVALUATION

08/04/2005 NTC: RELEASE ORD & BOND D 1
NOT TO POSSESS FIREARMS OR DANGEROUS WEAPONS
NOT TO POSSESS OR CONSUME ALCOHOL OR ENTER LIQUOR
ESTABLISHMENTS
NOT TO VIOLATE ANY FEDERAL, STATE OR LOCAL CRIMINAL LAW
TO NOTIFY THE COURT OF ANY CHANGE OF ADDRESS
NOT TO LEAVE THE (COUNTY OF ROOSEVELT)
WITHOUT PERMISSION OF THE COURT
TO MAINTAIN CONTACT WITH MY ATTORNEY
TO AVOID ALL CONTACT WITH THE ALLEGED VICTIM OR ANYONE WHO
MAY TESTIFY IN THIS CASE
UNSECURED APPEARANCE BOND OF $3000.00
APPEAR WHEN NOTIFIED
RELEASED TO HIS WIFE ONLY

08/03/2005 MISC ENTRY D 1
BOND/DISPOSTION SHEET
BOND $3000 APPEARANCE
ADDITIONAL CONDITIONS OF RELEASE: NOT TO LEAVE THE COUNTY
OF ROOSEVELT AND RELEASE TO CUSTODY OF WIFE

05/18/2005 NTC: TRANSFER ORD D 1
AN ISSUE HAVING BEEN RAISED AS TO THE MENTAL COMPETENCY OF T
HE DEF TO STAND TRIAL.

05/18/2005 NTC: TITLE PAGE TRANSCRIPT D 1

05/18/2005 CAL: PRE-TRIAL CONFERENCE D 1
Calendar Posting on 04-19-2005
05/18/2005 HRD :HEARD

05/10/2005 NTC: DEMAND JURY TRIAL D 1

05/10/2005 MTN: TO REVIEW COND RELEASE D 1

05/10/2005 ENTRY OF APPEARANCE FILED D 1
DM FILED BY PUBLIC DEF

04/19/2005 NTC: CRIMINAL PRETRIAL CONFER D 1
5-18-05 @ 1:30 PM

04/18/2005 NTC: ORD OF APPT D 1

04/18/2005 VIDEO ARRAIGNMENT HELD D 1
THE DEF DID NOT ENTER A PLEA
HE WOULD LIKE AN ATTORNEY, CANNOT HIRE HIS OWN
BOND $3000 100% CASH ONLY
ORD OF APPT

04/18/2005 CAL: ARRAIGNMENT D 1
Calendar Posting on 04-18-2005
04/19/2005 HRD :HEARD

04/18/2005 STATEMENT OF PROBABLE CAUSE D 1

04/18/2005 OPN: CRIMINAL COMPLAINT FILED
DM FILED BY CHARLES SMART, PPD FOR DISORDERLY CONDUCT;
RESISTING, EVADING, OBSTRUCTING AN OFFICER ON 4/17/05
-- Judge Assignment History --
Assign Date Judge Name Sequence # Assignment Event Desc
04/18/2005 JANE A MARTIN 1
-- Criminal Charge Details for --
Count Seq Charge Charge Dt Citation #MILLER SHAWN D 1
1 1 30-20-1-DISORDERLY CONDUCT 04/17/2005
Plea: Disp: 1A-CRB: DISMISSED BY PROSECUTOR Disp Date: 10/17/2005

2 1 30-22-1-RESISTING/EVADING/OBSTRUCTING AN OFFICER 04/17/2005
Plea: Disp: 1A-CRB: DISMISSED BY PROSECUTOR Disp Date: 10/17/2005

601-544-3968
331 Cook Rd. Moselle, Ms 39459