portland independent media center  
images audio video
newswire article reposts united states

media criticism

LIES and LYING LIARS

"Even if you don't worship the ground Howard Dean walks on, you should be disgruntled by this." (Or, at least, disgusted.)

"To be clear: The RNC is perpetuating a fraudulent quote on its website, days after the fraud has been debunked."
(from Daily Kos web site)

Lies and lying liars . . .


Even if you don't worship the ground Howard Dean walks on, you should be disgruntled by this.

On CNN's "Inside Politics," Robert Novak made up a quote by Dean by misreading something he said at Cornell.

Here was what Dean said, according to the Cornell Daily Sun.

Dean pointed out that, while he would not endorse this, if Social Security were left alone for 30 years, its benefits would be reduced to 80 percent of what it is now. He acknowledged that while there were indeed problems with the program, turning to Wall Street was not the answer.

Notice the math here. If you reduce something to "80 percent of what it is now," you are reducing it by 20 percent. You reduce $10,000 to $8,000. Why am I explaining simple math?

On CNN, here is what Robert Novak said.

"[T]hey've got to really get Howard under control. He spoke at Cornell University last week, and the only paper that covered this was "The Cornell Daily" student paper, and he said, yes, Social Security has a big problem. Over the years it's going to lose about 80 percent of the benefits. That, Judy, is not the Democratic line. The Democratic line is there is no problem."

Note Novak's math. If something is "going to lose about 80 percent," there will only be 20% left. $10,000 becomes $2,000.

Another version of this quote was debunked by David Brock's Media Matters on February 26. But on its website, today, the Republican National Committee has repeated Novak's quote in its news section, "In Case You Missed It."

To be clear: The RNC is perpetuating a fraudulent quote on its website, days after the fraud has been debunked.

Anyone want to email CNN or the RNC about this?
Have you heard the joke? 02.Mar.2005 02:48

U. Sam

How many republicans does it take to screw in a lightbulb? None. They just pay democrats to do it for them.

Let them lie, pretty soon they'll be talking to themselves. Then, maybe they'll start attacking some third parties. I'd like to see the MSM go after someone differen't for a change. The democrats are boring now. How many times can you attack Dean, kennedy, and kerry, it's played out. Let's see them go after some real opposition. Think that will happen?