portland independent media center  
images audio video
newswire article commentary oregon & cascadia

gender & sexuality

Lara vs. Luers- Equal Justice?

Op-ed piece in the Eugene Weekly about cop rapist Juan Francisco Lara's sentence of 5 years vs. polticial prisoner Jeffrey 'Free' Luers' 23 year sentence
Equal Justice?
Why did Lara get less than five years?

On Feb. 26 former Eugene Police officer Juan Francisco Lara was sentenced to less than five years for crimes relating to sexual abuse of women and other acts of misconduct while on duty. Eleven victims spoke at the hearing about how Lara's actions have irrevocably changed their lives for the worse. Many of the victims reported that they were so afraid of Lara that they had to move away from Eugene.

Lara never took responsibility for his crimes, and instead attempted the age-old defense that the women wanted it. The hearing revealed Lara's own boastful admissions that he was "just thinking with his dick," and that his job was all about "getting a piece of ass." The plea deal was arranged in a shady after-hours proceeding where this rapist was even allowed to weasel out of being convicted as a sex offender!

The bust of Lara (and of Roger Magaña, currently in jail awaiting trial) is just the tip of the iceberg. The EPD is filled with cops who abuse their power as police officers every day and severely violate the public's trust.

I wonder if the new chief intends to really clean house or just make public scapegoats of these two cops. Will any officers be suspended or fired as a result of the investigation into the sex crimes? One thing is clear: They need to clean up their act before coming to the community for more tax money!

Let's clearly show this travesty of justice for what it really is. Perhaps you recall the case of Jeffrey Luers. On June 16, 2000, this 22-year-old man set three SUVs on fire in the Romania car lot to make a political statement. The punishment for this minor property crime: 22.5 years in prison! There were no backroom deals in this case; as a matter of fact, there were no plea offers made to him at all. The only victim in this case was a car dealership that collected a hefty insurance check.

What did the women who were raped and victimized by Lara get? Nothing. They did not receive a dime in victim compensation (although the DA asked for it, the judge denied it) and were harshly cross-examined by Lara's defense attorney, Dan Koenig. They were humiliated by the slap on the wrist that Lara received in this plea bargain proceeding, and now must attempt to get on with their lives.

It is appalling and outrageous that a young man has been sentenced to 22.5 years for a minor arson, and an officer sworn to uphold the law and protect the community has been sentenced to 54 months by the exact same court of law for sexually abusing while in uniform at least 10 women in this community without even having to register as a sex offender — a title he has more than earned by his own deviant, dishonest and evil actions. This situation makes a mockery of the courts, the criminal justice system and equal protection of the law — the foundation of the U.S. Constitution.
Jim Flynn is an 11-year Eugene resident and police critic who was repeatedly pepper-sprayed by EPD officers at the June 1, 1997, protest of downtown tree removal to build the Broadway/Charnelton project.


homepage: homepage: http://www.freefreenow.org
address: address: http://www.breakthechains.net

The Difference 19.Mar.2004 10:26

Monty Crisco

Luers is a political prisoner of war (there are few such, as these people are real heros).

Lara is just a common criminal (there are many such, especially in police departments).

Historically, political prisoners have always done more time than common criminals, that is until revolution finally happens.

an added difference 19.Mar.2004 10:46


I would further distinguish that as a police officer, Lara is a common criminal who was part of "the system"* and that afforded him much additional privelege.

* shorthand for, executor of that power of the State from which all other powers flow - monopoly on the "legitimate" use of force.

How Ironic 19.Mar.2004 13:21


If all the SUVs in the US were replaced by average mpg cars we wouldnt need mideast oil and we could end our occupation of the mideast and the war on terrorism would be over.