Could the WH Press Corps be growing some backbone???
White House Press Briefing - TANG Records Released
Wednesday, 11 February 2004, 10:57 am
Press Release: The White House
For Immediate Release
Office of the Press Secretary
February 10, 2004
Press Briefing by Scott McClellan
The James S. Brady Briefing Room
12:53 P.M. EST
MR. McCLELLAN: Good afternoon. The President, a short time ago,
concluded his meeting with some economic leaders. This was a good
discussion about the steps that we have taken to strengthen our
economy, and the additional steps that we are calling on Congress to
take to strengthen our economy even more, so that we can create as
robust an environment as possible for job creation.
A lot of the issues that were discussed centered on addressing rising
health care costs, promoting trade, making the tax cuts permanent, and
passing a comprehensive energy plan. Those are all important parts of
the President's six-point plan to strengthen our economy even more.
And that's the quick readout from the meeting. With that, I'll be glad
to go right into your questions.
Q On the attendance records of the National Guard, it said he had 56
out of a required 50 points. Is that considered a good attendance
record, do you know? Or do you know what the maximum number of points
you can get --
MR. McCLELLAN: First of all, we were pleased to be able to provide you
all with these additional records that just recently came to our
attention. These documents clearly show that the President fulfilled
his duties. And we had previously released some of the point summaries
that you are referencing. There is more complete information relating
to those point summaries that document the fact that the President of
the United States fulfilled his duties when he was serving in the
National Guard back in the early '70s.
Q Scott, a couple of questions I have -- the records that you handed
out today, and other records that exist, indicate that the President
did not perform any Guard duty during the months of December 1972,
February or March of 1973. I'm wondering if you can tell us where he
was during that period. And also, how is it that he managed to not make
the medical requirements to remain on active flight duty status?
MR. McCLELLAN: John, the records that you're pointing to, these records
are the payroll records; they're the point summaries. These records
verify that he met the requirements necessary to fulfill his duties.
These records --
Q That wasn't my question, Scott.
MR. McCLELLAN: These payroll records --
Q Scott, that wasn't my question, and you know it wasn't my question.
Where was he in December of '72, February and March of '73? And why did
he not fulfill the medical requirements to remain on active flight duty
MR. McCLELLAN: These records -- these records I'm holding here clearly
document the President fulfilling his duties in the National Guard. The
President was proud of his service. The President --
Q I asked a simple question; how about a simple answer?
MR. McCLELLAN: John, if you'll let me address the question, I'm coming
to your answer, and I'd like --
Q Well, if you would address it -- maybe you could.
MR. McCLELLAN: I'm sorry, John. But this is an important issue that
some chose to raise in the context of an election year, and the facts
are important for people to know. And if you don't want to know the
facts, that's fine. But I want to share the facts with you.
Q I do want to know the facts, which is why I keep asking the question.
And I'll ask it one more time. Where was he in December of '72,
February and March of '73? Why didn't he fulfill the medical
requirements to remain on active flight duty status in 1972?
MR. McCLELLAN: The President recalls serving both when he was in Texas
and when he was in Alabama. And that is what I can tell you. And we
have provided you these documents that show clearly that the President
of the United States fulfilled his duties. And that is the reason that
he was honorably discharged from the National Guard. The President was
proud of his service.
The President spent some of that time in Texas. He was a member of the
Texas Air National Guard, and he was given permission, on a temporary
basis, to perform equivalent duty while he was in Alabama. And he
performed that duty. And the payroll records, that I think are very
important for the public to have, clearly reflect that he served.
Q Scott, when Senator Kerry goes around campaigning, there's frequently
what they call "a band of brothers," a bunch of soldiers who served
with him, who come forward and give testimonials for him. I see, in
looking at our files in the campaign of 2000, it said that you were
looking for people who served with him to verify his account of service
in the National Guard. Has the White House been able to find, like
Senator Kerry, "a band of brothers" or others who can testify about the
MR. McCLELLAN: All the information that we have we shared with you in
2000, that was relevant to this issue. And all the additional
information that has come to our attention we have shared with you. The
President was asked about this in his interview over the weekend, and
the President made it clear, yes, I want all records to be made
available that are relevant to this issue; that there are some out
there that were making outrageous, baseless accusations. It was a shame
that they brought it up four years ago. It was a shame that they
brought it up again this year. And I think that the facts are very
clear from these documents. These documents -- the payroll records and
the point summaries verify that he was paid for serving and that he met
Q Actually, I wasn't talking about documents, I was talking about
people -- you know, comrades-in-arms --
MR. McCLELLAN: Right. That's why I said everything that came to our
attention that was available, we made available at that time, during
the 2000 campaign.
Q But you said you were looking for people -- and I take it you didn't
find any people?
MR. McCLELLAN: I mean, obviously, we would have made people available.
And we -- Mr. Lloyd, who has provided a statement to put some of this
into context for everybody, made some public statements during that
time period to verify the records that the President had fulfilled his
duties. And he put out an additional statement now to put this into
context. He's someone with some technical expertise and someone that
understands these matters, because he was in the National Guard at the
Q Scott, can I follow on this, because I do think this is important.
You know, it might strike some as odd that there isn't anyone who can
stand up and say, I served with George W. Bush in Alabama, or in
Houston in the Guard unit. Particularly because there are people, his
superiors who have stepped forward -- in Alabama and in Houston -- who
have said in the past several years that they have no recollection of
him being there and serving. So isn't that odd that nobody -- you can't
produce anyone to corroborate what these records purport to show?
MR. McCLELLAN: David, we're talking about some 30 years ago. You are
perfectly welcome to go back and talk to individuals from that time
period. But these documents --
Q Hey, we're trying. But I would have thought you guys would have had a
real good handle on --
MR. McCLELLAN: - these documents make it very clear that the President
of the United States fulfilled his duties --
Q Well, that's subject to interpretation.
MR. McCLELLAN: No. When you serve, you are paid for that service. And
these documents outline the days on which he was paid. That means he
served. And these documents also show that he met his requirements. And
it's just really a shame that people are continuing to bring this issue
up. When --
Q I understand --
MR. McCLELLAN: No, no, no, no. People asked for records to be released
that would demonstrate he met his requirements. The records have now
been fully released. The facts are clear --
Q Do you know that a lot of these payroll records are --
MR. McCLELLAN: -- the facts are clear --
Q -- you can't read them. Have you looked at these? You can't -- how
are we supposed to read these?
MR. McCLELLAN: Well, I think you can talk -- one, we put it out on
email. It's a lot easier to read, I think, on the email version because
that was the --
Q Oh, you did put it on our email?
MR. McCLELLAN: We are going to, if we haven't already. But it was sent
to us in email form from the Personnel Center in Denver, Colorado.
Q One other thing on this. To corroborate these records, will the
President do two things -- one, will he authorize the relevant defense
agency in Colorado to release actual pay stubs for the President? And
if those don't exist, will the President file a form, as he can do at
the IRS, to at least look for a '72 or '73 tax return that would
corroborate what you claim are payroll summaries that he actually got
paid for this duty?
MR. McCLELLAN: Well, I think this information is his payroll records.
It is my understanding this is the information that is available from
his payroll records. And it shows the days on which he was paid. So
that's the information that I understand is available. In terms of tax
returns, the President, like most Americans, does not have his tax
returns from some 30 years ago.
Q But it's possible that he could file a form requesting the IRS to
search if they have a return for '72 or '73. Is he willing to do that?
MR. McCLELLAN: Obviously, if there's any additional information that
came to our attention that was relevant, we would make that information
Q Well, it could be relevant if he would file a form --
MR. McCLELLAN: I think that these documents clearly show that the
President of the United States fulfilled his duties. I mean, these were
the documents that people questioned and said should be made available.
And we went back to double-check. We thought we had all the information
that existed previously, but we went back to double-check after the
comments that were made over the weekend, to see if there was any
additional information available. And when we contacted the Personnel
Center in Colorado, it was our understanding that the Personnel Center
in St. Louis and Colorado were already working to pull this information
together, and that this is the information that they have that is
relevant to this topic.
Q So it's your position and it's the President's position that these
documents put this issue to rest, period?
MR. McCLELLAN: Oh, I think these documents show that he fulfilled his
duties. These documents show that he met his requirements.
Q Scott, two questions, one on the documents, one on the issue. There
seems to be a discrepancy now in the President's record that I wondered
if you could help me with. These documents that you're holding up show
that the President showed up for duty in October and November of '72,
January, April and May of '73. But the President's officer
effectiveness report, filed by his commanders, Lieutenants Colonel
Killean and Harris, both now deceased, for the period 01 May '72 to 30
April, '73, says he has not been observed at this unit, where he was
supposed to show up and earning these points on these days. How do you
MR. McCLELLAN: You're talking about which unit?
Q The Texas -- at the Ellington Air Force Base.
MR. McCLELLAN: From '72 to '73?
Q Correct. And certainly by -- the President said he returned to Texas
in November of '72. So some of these dates of service, which are in
these records, ought to have been noted by his commanding officers,
who, nevertheless, said, twice, he has not been observed here. Can you
MR. McCLELLAN: I'm not sure about these specific documents. I'll be
glad to take a look at them. But these documents show the days on which
he was paid for his service. And the President -- as I've said, and we
previously said during the 2000 campaign -- recalls serving both in
Texas and in Alabama during the time period you're bringing up.
Q So he served, but his commanding officers didn't know it?
MR. McCLELLAN: Again, I don't know the specific documents you're
referring to. If you want to bring those to me, I'll be glad to take a
look at them and get you the answers to your questions.
Q Okay. Then on the general issue, Senator Kerry has said that the
National Guard was one way for people to avoid service in Vietnam. The
President and the White House have taken umbrage at that, saying that's
denigrating the National Guard. In 1994, the President told the Houston
Chronicle, in relation to his joining the National Guard, "I was not
prepared to shoot my eardrum out with a shotgun in order to get a
deferment, nor was I willing to go to Canada, so I chose to better
myself by learning how to fly airplanes." It sounds like the President,
himself, acknowledged that he went into the National Guard because he
didn't want to go to Vietnam.
MR. McCLELLAN: The President -- again, Terry, this issue has been
addressed fully. Now we're trying to change into different issues here.
The President was proud of his service in the National Guard. He
fulfilled his duties; he was honorably discharged. I think there are
some that we're now seeing are not interested in the facts. What they
are interested in is trying to twist the facts for partisan political
advantage in an election year. And that's unfortunate.
Q It is a partisan issue. I'm not doubting that, I'm trying to explore
it. One of the reasons the Democrats are raising it is because they've
got a guy who was in Vietnam.
MR. McCLELLAN: Now it's -- he didn't serve, now it's a different issue
-- when the facts clearly show that he did serve, he did fulfill his
duties, he did meet his requirements, he was honorably discharged.
Q But he didn't want to go to Vietnam.
MR. McCLELLAN: I think the facts are clear. It's clear that some are
not interested in the facts. It's clear that some may be more
interested in using this for partisan political advantage.
Q Scott, these are very hard to read, these payroll documents. Are you
saying that every date listed on document five is a day that the
President was actually -- showed up, he was suited up, he was flying
planes -- that's what that means? Because there are, you know, points
for active duty, points for inactive duty. What, exactly, are these?
MR. McCLELLAN: Well, and that's why we put out the statement from Mr.
Lloyd, so you could put that in context. He's someone with the
technical expertise that understands those matters and can explain what
those points mean. And I think that his statement does that. In terms
of the payments, you are paid for the days on which you serve.
Q The days on which you serve, meaning he was actually there on these
dates listed, he was actually there --
MR. McCLELLAN: You are paid for the days you serve.
Q Is that what document five is, the dates he served?
MR. McCLELLAN: Again, there was a time period when he was in Alabama,
and he recalls serving in Alabama. He was still a member of the Texas
Air National Guard at that time. What he was doing was performing
equivalent duty, because he was working in Alabama at the time. And he
also remembers serving in Texas, as well.
Q Scott, so, for example, in January '73, the President served,
according to this, on January 4th, January 5th, January 6th in either
Texas or Alabama -- according to document five. Is that correct?
MR. McCLELLAN: You are paid for the days you serve. You have the
documents right in front of you. These are documents straight from the
Q Is that "yes"?
MR. McCLELLAN: -- straight from the Personnel Center in Colorado.
Q Is that "yes"?
MR. McCLELLAN: I said you are paid for the days in which you serve.
And, again, we're talking about 30 years ago, Elisabeth. The President
recalls serving in Alabama. He also recalls serving in Texas. That's
what he recalls. And that's why --
Q But, again, -- I know you're going to bat this down, but there are
people who --
MR. McCLELLAN: You know, there were a lot of people calling for these
records to be released. We finally came across these records. They have
been released, and these documents reflect the fact that the President
met his requirements and fulfilled his duties.
Q And the fact that some of his officers don't recall ever seeing him,
are you suggesting that they just don't remember after 30 years?
MR. McCLELLAN: Well, I think I'll let them speak for themselves. I'm
not sure that they exactly said it in that way. Some different ones
said different things.
Q They have. They have spoken for themselves. They don't remember.
Q What is your answer to them about why they don't remember seeing the
MR. McCLELLAN: That the President recalls serving. I just said that.
Q But why are they saying this?
MR. McCLELLAN: And if you look at the records, if you look at these
records, these records document that the President fulfilled his
duties. These records reflect that he met his requirements, both in
point summaries and that he was paid for the days in which he served.
Q Scott, can you just clarify, back to Elisabeth's question here on
document five? For example, in February and March of '73, there are no
dates that appear, meaning he didn't show up then, or what --
MR. McCLELLAN: Well, look, I mean, we're talking about 30 years ago,
again. And these documents show the dates on which he was paid, which
means those are the days on which you serve.
Q Does that mean, then, that he --
MR. McCLELLAN: I don't have -- Roger, I'm sorry, I don't have an
hour-by-hour itemization of everything he was doing 30 years ago.
Q Are you able to make out any of the paid amounts? How much did he
get? I can't read the letters.
MR. McCLELLAN: And again, this is going to be put out in the email
version, as well, and you're welcome to contact the Personnel Center.
I'm sure that they will be glad to help you, as well.
Q Scott, may I re-ask Dana's question? You keep saying he served -- he
fulfilled his duty, he met his requirements. You're not saying, he
drilled, he showed up, he attended. Is that intentional?
MR. McCLELLAN: No, he recalls performing his duties, both in Alabama
and Texas. I said that in response to Elisabeth's question.
Q Define that.
MR. McCLELLAN: Well, again, I don't have a minute-by-minute breakdown
of every single thing he did throughout that time period.
Q What did he do?
Q You keep saying the word, "serve." Define "serve."
MR. McCLELLAN: He met -- he served both in Alabama, and he served both
Q Doing what? Did that period -- can you at least tell us the
difference between inactive -- because it's not clear in these
MR. McCLELLAN: No, I think that I'll leave it to those who can explain
these documents to do the explaining. That's why we put the statement
from Mr. Lloyd, who was in the National Guard at the time; he was
someone that had the expertise to explain to you what these points
mean. And that's why we provided that statement. Obviously, the
Personnel Center can tell you more about what everything means on these
documents. We just received these late yesterday.
But the one thing that these documents clearly show is that the
President of the United States fulfilled his duties when he was in the
National Guard. He met his requirements and he was honorably discharged
because he fulfilled his duties.
Q Just so I can be sure that I'm interpreting this crystal-clearly --
you're not making any claim here that the President attended, showed
up, drilled on these days?
MR. McCLELLAN: I'm telling you that he did -- he does recall showing up
and performing his duties. And you're paid for the days on which you
serve. And that's what these documents reflect.
Q Scott, is it your --
MR. McCLELLAN: We're going to stay on this topic, and then we'll jump
to other topics.
Q It's your position that these documents specifically show that he
served in Alabama during the period 1972, when he was supposed to be
there. Do they specifically show that?
MR. McCLELLAN: No, I think if you look at the documents, what they show
are the days on which he was paid, the payroll records. And we
previously said that the President recalls serving both in Alabama and
Q I'm not interested in what he recalls. I'm interested in whether
these documents specifically show that he was in Alabama and served on
the days during the latter part of 1972 --
MR. McCLELLAN: And I just answered that question.
Q You have not answered that question. You --
MR. McCLELLAN: No, I said -- no, I said, no, in response to your
Q No, so the answer is, "no"?
MR. McCLELLAN: I said these documents show the days on which he was
paid. That's what they show. So they show -- they show that he was paid
on these days.
Q Okay, but they do not show that he was in Alabama when he was
supposed to be --
MR. McCLELLAN: These are payroll records, and they reflect the fact
that he was paid on the days on which he served.
Q Do any of them show that he was paid on days that he served in the
latter part of 1972 when he was in Alabama? I don't see any dates for
MR. McCLELLAN: It just kind of amazes me that some will now say they
want more information, after the payroll records and the point
summaries have all been released to show that he met his requirements
and to show that he fulfilled his duties.
Q But these documents do not show that. They do not show that he was in
Alabama and served at that time. I don't even see any pay dates during
MR. McCLELLAN: They show payments. No, they show pay dates during that
fall of 1972 period.
Q They do?
MR. McCLELLAN: There's October on there, there's November on there, and
then there's January on there, as well, in '73. There's some pay dates
Q Okay, so then, do they specifically show that he served in Alabama
during that time?
MR. McCLELLAN: They show payments in October; they show payments in
Q But just because he's paid doesn't mean that he served and worked
there, does it?
Q Come on.
MR. McCLELLAN: You know, like I said, people call on us to release the
records. We didn't even know they still existed until just the other
day. Now we've released the records, which document that the President
fulfilled his duties. And now people are trying to move the goalpost
Q You said in Alabama that he had served equivalent duty.
MR. McCLELLAN: That's right.
Q Can you describe what that was, and what -- why did he need to move
to Alabama? What was --
MR. McCLELLAN: Like I said, Greg, you're asking me to kind of break
down hour-by-hour what he was doing during 1972 and 1973. What these
documents show is that he was serving in the National Guard and he was
paid for that service. And they show that he was serving in the
National Guard and that he met the requirements necessary to fulfill
Q But his equivalent duty, does that he mean there was a base there he
was flying out of? Is that what he recalls?
MR. McCLELLAN: I'd have to go back and double-check, but he remembers
serving during that period and performing his duties, both in Alabama
and in Texas.
And these are -- look, these are questions we addressed all during the
campaign. The issue that came up recently was some were trying to make
an outrageous, baseless accusation. If I recall, some were using the
comment, "deserter" or "AWOL." I mean, that is outrageous; it is
baseless. The President of the United States fulfilled his duties, he
was honorably discharged. And now there are some that are not -- are
clearly not interested in the facts. They're clearly more interested in
twisting the facts to seek a partisan political advantage in the
context of an election year. And that's just really unfortunate that
some would stoop to such a level.
Q Scott, what is it that took him to Alabama?
MR. McCLELLAN: I'm sorry?
Q -- that took him to Alabama?
MR. McCLELLAN: It was a campaign, a senatorial campaign.
Q Scott, we all know people who tomorrow may not show up for work and
will be paid. And their payrolls will show they were paid.
MR. McCLELLAN: Well, again, when you're serving in the National Guard
you're paid for the days on which you serve. I mean, it's specifically
related to the service.
Q Could you walk us through the sequence of events in the last few days
that led to the production of these records?
MR. McCLELLAN: Sure, sure.
Q And did those efforts begin after or before the interview with --
MR. McCLELLAN: No, it was after. The questions came up in the interview
on "Meet the Press," and the President made it very clear, some of what
I'm saying here. And he said, yes, I want all records out there. And it
was our belief, it was our impression that all the records that existed
that were relevant were already released. Back in the 2000 campaign, we
went to the Texas Air National Guard to ask for records so that they
could be released, and it was our understanding that the payroll
records -- it was our impression at the time that the payroll records
Then after this weekend, after the interview, we contacted the National
Guard here and asked them where would one go, if these records existed,
to find them. We were just going back and double-checking. And we were
put in touch with the Personnel Center in Denver, Colorado. So we
contacted the Personnel Center in Denver, Colorado. It was our
understanding at that time that the Denver and St. Louis offices were
already working to pull this information together at the time that we
contacted them --
Q On their own?
MR. McCLELLAN: That's correct. They could explain more about why they
were doing that.
Q Did you contact them on Monday, Scott?
MR. McCLELLAN: I'll double-check. I believe it would have been probably
Monday before we were able to reach them. So, yesterday -- yes,
yesterday. I know there were conversations yesterday.
Q Who initiated the conversations?
MR. McCLELLAN: Oh, Dan Bartlett, from here, Communications Director.
Anyway, so he contacted them and found out that there was, indeed,
additional payroll records. And the President authorized that those be
made available, as he said he was going to do. He said he wanted all
the records released that existed, that were relevant. And to our
knowledge, this is all the records that exist that are relevant to this
Q The letter from Colonel Lloyd says that he assessed the records. Did
-- there's no indication that he had any direct oversight of President
Bush. Did he?
MR. McCLELLAN: I'm sorry?
Q That Lt. Colonel Lloyd, did he have any direct oversight over
President Bush at the time he served?
MR. McCLELLAN: I think he could address those questions, in terms of
what his role was at the time in the National Guard. But he was
certainly someone that had the technical expertise to be able to
explain what the point summaries mean, in terms of the numbers, and
what they reflect. So that's what he did. And he stated -- he made some
comments back during the 2000 campaign; I'm sure you can go back and
look at those, as well.
Q Just to be clear, what he's saying today is that his assessment of
the records is that the requirements were fulfilled.
MR. McCLELLAN: That the requirements were met. His own words are in his
statements so I would refer you straight back to his words.
Q When did Lloyd make this memorandum?
MR. McCLELLAN: This one?
MR. McCLELLAN: In the last day. I think we received it yesterday from
Q -- one date that I was --
MR. McCLELLAN: Yes.
Q Are you ready to take questions on a different subject?
MR. McCLELLAN: We're still on this topic, right?
Q Since there have been so many questions about what the President was
doing over 30 years ago, what is it that he did after his honorable
discharge from the National Guard? Did he make speeches alongside Jane
Fonda, denouncing America's racist war in Vietnam? Did he testify
before Congress that American troops committed war crimes in Vietnam?
And did he throw somebody else's medals at the White House to protest a
war America was still fighting? What was he doing after he was
MR. McCLELLAN: We've already commented on some of his views relating
back to that period the other day. And, obviously, this was a time
period also when he was going to get his MBA at Harvard. But the
President was certainly proud to serve in the National Guard.
Q And would the White House consider those actions by Senator Kerry,
that Jeff mentions fair game in the political season?
MR. McCLELLAN: Terry, I think -- I know that that's a way to try to
draw us into a Democratic primary that is ongoing.
Q You're there, my friend. (Laughter.)
MR. McCLELLAN: Well, this is an important matter that some have chosen
-- some have chosen to twist the facts. And it's important that the
facts are clear. And I think that these documents clearly show that the
President met his requirements and fulfilled his duties. But, look,
we'll let the Democratic primary continue. They can work out their
differences. I think if you have questions to address to people that
made certain accusations, you should direct them to those individuals.
Because now, in light of these documents, this is new information that
clearly shows otherwise to what they were suggesting.
Q Scott, the President said clearly --
MR. McCLELLAN: Let me keep going. I'll come back to you.
Q Wait a second --
MR. McCLELLAN: We have a few in the back. I'll come back to you, I
promise. But let me try to get to everybody in the room. I promise I'll
come back to you. Ben I think had one, and then April. And did you have
another one, Ron? Kind of slipped one in there.
Q The records show, between April 16, 1972 and October 28th there was
no pay period, he wasn't paid. That was when he was in Alabama. Now,
you said some of the payroll records were lost, but that you know he
didn't serve. And was this the President remembering he didn't serve?
MR. McCLELLAN: I think it was for the fall period, when he -- and
again, I'd have to go back and look at the exact dates of when he was
in Alabama. But it was during the fall that he made a request to
perform equivalent duty in Alabama again. That was still a period when
he would be a member of the Texas Air National Guard. But I'd have to
go back and double-check those exact dates that he was in Alabama.
Q -- wouldn't have been paid for equivalent duty?
MR. McCLELLAN: I'm sorry?
Q You wouldn't be paid for equivalent duty.
MR. McCLELLAN: You're paid for serving. And equivalent duty is
performing your duties for the Texas Air National Guard.
Q But the summary sheets state that he did not perform service in the
third quarter of --
MR. McCLELLAN: These are not our summary sheets, these are the summary
sheets from the Personnel Center in Colorado.
Q -- payroll records were lost, but also, we know he didn't perform
service in that third quarter.
MR. McCLELLAN: You are paid for the days on which you serve.
Q So when he was in Alabama during that quarter, he didn't perform
MR. McCLELLAN: Well, again, I'm not sure that he was in Alabama during
that whole period you are talking about. I'd have to go back and look.
He requested -- I know that he requested to perform equivalent duty
during that fall time period when he was in Alabama. You are going back
further than that. I'd have to double-check.
Q He left in May, I believe --
MR. McCLELLAN: I'd have to double-check the time period in which he was
Q Is this cumulative, the sort of thing you don't have to perform every
month, it's just a matter of, out of the course of a year, you get your
MR. McCLELLAN: You know, I'm not -- there are people that have
technical expertise in these matters. I think they're the National
Guard. You can direct those questions to those individuals. I'm sure
that they would be glad to try to help you out.
Q You keep saying this is a shame, and you're talking partisan
politics, but don't you think the American public, as well,
particularly the U.S. military, who has been tested right now with the
fact that they went to war on faulty intelligence, possibly, and now
finding out that their Commander-in-Chief possibly tried to avoid going
to the Vietnam War -- don't you think that the American public is owed
a little bit more than photo copies that we can't see things of? Don't
you think the military is owed a little bit more than just, "he served"?
MR. McCLELLAN: April, I'm really sorry that you phrased that question
the way you did, some of it, when you were saying that they're owed
more than the documents that show that he served during that time
period. Now, let me go back --
Q But wouldn't someone know what he did?
MR. McCLELLAN: And the President -- we have previously said, going back
to the 2000 campaign and even before that, that he recalls performing
his duties, both in Alabama and in Texas, during the time period that
some have questioned. So let's be very clear about that. Let's be very
clear about the facts. Because the American people should have the
facts, and the facts are right here in these documents. The facts are
right here in these documents.
Q We can't see facts. We can't see -- these facts are very messed up,
MR. McCLELLAN: April, I mentioned earlier that we were going to be
putting this out on email, if we haven't already, because it was sent
to us in email form. You are also welcome to contact the Personnel
Center in Denver, Colorado. I am sure that they will be glad to walk
you through this.
Q You're saying that this is political -- this is all politics and
everything and people are obscuring in putting the facts up. But people
are not able to stand up for the President. There are dates that aren't
accounted for. You can't even tell us what kind of drills or
what-have-you. What do you say to the U.S. military --
MR. McCLELLAN: No, we addressed all those questions back during the
2000 campaign fully. Let me be very clear: The issue that came up
recently was an outrageous, baseless accusation suggesting that the
President did not serve and did not meet his requirements. People
called on us to release records that might be available to show that
he, indeed -- that he, indeed, did meet his requirements and serve and
fulfill his duties. The records have been released. These records
document that the President fulfilled his duties. Now people are
wanting to go further than that. And these are the records that reflect
Q You can detail your job. You can detail what you do as Press
MR. McCLELLAN: And we did. During the 2000 campaign, we talked about
this issue fully. You're now going to a different issue. These issues --
Q It's still the same issue --
MR. McCLELLAN: Let me be very clear here about this. There are some
that made some very outrageous accusations about the President's time
in the National Guard. There was a call for us to release payroll
records. The payroll records have been released, as they just came to
our attention and we shared them with you very quickly. The point
summaries showing that he met his requirements have been released.
Those were records that were -- that some called on us to release. We
didn't know that some of these records previously existed. Obviously,
if they had, we would have been glad to share them with everybody at
This issue was addressed fully four years ago. Like I said, it was
really a shame that it came up four years ago, and it's really a shame
that it's being brought up again this year. The facts are clear. Now,
there may be some out there that are not interested in the facts. And
those people clearly are simply more interested in trying to seek a
partisan political advantage in election year, then the facts. That's
Q I don't really have a question that goes to the politics of this. I
just want to ask a question about a contradiction, and a question about
a specific record. After all of the things you repeated here, you
cannot explain this contradiction, the fact that his payroll records
indicate he was paid for a period of time for fulfilling service, and
yet his commanding officers at that time wrote that he was not
observed. Can you or can you not explain that contradiction?
MR. McCLELLAN: If you're talking about the question that Terry brought
up, I said I would glad to go back and look at the document that he's
referencing. I have not --
Q You know the document he's referencing. Everybody does. His
MR. McCLELLAN: No, I have not -- I have not seen the document he's
Q -- are quoted repeatedly for years --
MR. McCLELLAN: You're talking about quotes -- you're talking about
quotes from individuals. And we said for years, going back four years
ago, that the President recalls serving and performing his duties.
Q I understand that, but his commanders do not recall it. And, in fact,
they say, that he was not observed. So can you explain the
contradiction, or can't you?
MR. McCLELLAN: I've seen some different comments he's -- no, I've seen
some different comments made over the recent time period.
Q I haven't seen any different -- different comments from Brigadier
General Turnipseed, not from his Ellington commanders, who said he was
not observed. Can you explain the contradiction?
MR. McCLELLAN: Look, I can't speak for those individuals. I can speak
for the President of the United States. And I can speak --
Q -- the documents --
MR. McCLELLAN: And I can speak for the fact that the documents that --
as far as we know, all the documents that are available relevant to
this issue demonstrate that the President fulfilled his duties. Are you
suggesting these documents do not reflect that?
Q I'm not suggesting -- I'm asking, that's all I'm doing. Here's the
second point, the President said to Tim Russert, very specifically, on
Sunday, that he would be willing to provide pay stub records and tax
return records to corroborate --
MR. McCLELLAN: And we addressed this situation previously.
Q -- wait a second -- to corroborate --
MR. McCLELLAN: It's the second time you've asked this question.
Q Right, and I'll ask it until we maybe get something -- which is to
corroborate these payroll records that are coming from one source. Will
he request that all the records are released, from Denver and from St.
Louis, to prove that he actually received money, not just that they say
MR. McCLELLAN: These are the payroll records that we understand are
available. This is it.
Q -- all that's there --
MR. McCLELLAN: It is our understanding that these are the payroll
records that are available, yes.
Q Just out of curiosity, how much money does a person get paid for each
day's service, and is there any evidence that George W. Bush might not
have accepted the money, might have turned it down?
MR. McCLELLAN: Oh, Connie, you'd have to go back and ask at the time
what the pay was. Again, it shows the dates on which he was paid. And I
think this goes into some of the amounts here on these papers.
Q Scott, new subject?
MR. McCLELLAN: Same subject?
MR. McCLELLAN: Go ahead.
Q Am I wrong in reading document five that he didn't perform any days
of service between April 16 and October 28 --
MR. McCLELLAN: Yes, we've been through this. Again, the documents --
Q I want to make sure that's correct.
MR. McCLELLAN: -- well, those are the documents. You have them right in
front of you. I'm not disputing these documents. In fact, I'm saying
that these documents demonstrate that the President fulfilled his
duties. These are the payroll records.
Q Which of these dates refers to days he served in Alabama?
MR. McCLELLAN: I'm sorry?
Q Which of the dates in document five --
MR. McCLELLAN: If you look at the fall time period, that was a time
period that he was in Alabama. Again, Keith asked this question
earlier, and asked if it shows exactly where he was serving when he was
paid. And I said, no. I said, what these documents show is that he was
paid for the days on which he was -- served. These are the payroll
records that reflect the days on which he served.
Q On what date did he come back, did he return from Alabama?
MR. McCLELLAN: I think we've been through some of these issues
previously. I don't know the exact date off the top of my head. We'll
be glad to look back and try to get you that information. But those
were all questions that were addressed previously. The relevant issue
that was brought up by some recently was whether or not the President
had served. The documents clearly show that the President served and
met his requirements and fulfilled his duties.
Q Scott, could you just tell us, are these all the documents you got,
you received, here at the White House, from Colorado, or have you kept
some in reserve? And also --
MR. McCLELLAN: No, these --
Q -- do you expect any additional documents from St. Louis or from
MR. McCLELLAN: Well, as always, I said that we would -- if there is
additional information that comes to our attention, we will make sure
to get you that information. This is the information that we understand
is available from the Personnel Center in Denver, Colorado.
Q And that's all that they sent you, this is the extent of all the
MR. McCLELLAN: Yes, this is what they sent us. And we just put it in
our own email and sent it out for you all.
Q Scott, Dan Bartlett told the Associated Press, in June of 2000, that
he traveled to the Air Reserve Personnel Center and reviewed President
Bush's military file. He said, "I've read it, and there is nothing
earth-shattering." Did he see these documents when he reviewed the
file? Did he see any other documents when he reviewed the file? And was
there anything in the file --
MR. McCLELLAN: Well, that's a broad question about other documents. All
the relevant documents relating to his service have been released --
Q So has Dan Bartlett ever seen these documents?
MR. McCLELLAN: -- as we said. And as I said yesterday, everything that
we had we released in 2004 -- I mean, 2000, at the time, or during the
2000 campaign. It might have been '99.
Q There may be documents that were in that file --
MR. McCLELLAN: No, this is the first time this information has come to
Q So Dan Bartlett didn't see these documents --
MR. McCLELLAN: Again, I think I've answered this question up here, and
I've answered it back for you.
Q I've got one more --
MR. McCLELLAN: We're going to keep moving. Any more on this topic? Do
you have this topic, this topic? Then Wendell is a new subject. We're
off this topic.
Q Talk to me, Scott -- (laughter) -- about --
MR. McCLELLAN: I was trying to talk to John earlier, but he didn't want
me to talk.
Q I was trying to get an answer, but you didn't want to talk.
Q Tell us what you told --
MR. McCLELLAN: The cameras are on, and it's always great to have the
Q Ooooh --
Q Tell us what you told the FBI about the --
Q They're on you, my friend, not me.
Q -- the outing, if you will, of Valerie Plame?
MR. McCLELLAN: Wendell, the President has made it clear that he wants
to get to the bottom of this investigation. The leaking of classified
information is a very serious matter. The President directed everybody
at the White House to cooperate fully in the investigation. I,
obviously, want to do my part to cooperate. And if there's something
that can help those who are leading this investigation get to the
bottom of it, I am more than happy to share that information with them.
But if you have specific questions relating to an ongoing
investigation, those questions are best directed to the Department of
Justice. The Department of Justice is the one that is overseeing this
matter. I want to do everything I can, if there is anything I can do,
to help that investigation move forward so that we can get to the
bottom of this.
Q But there is no legal prohibition on you talking with us about what
you told them. So if you would, tell us what questions they asked you,
and tell us what answers you gave them. (Laughter.)
MR. McCLELLAN: Wendell, that is correct. But I think that it's best for
me to refer those questions to the Justice Department. Obviously, if
they think it is helpful to the investigation to share that
information, I am sure that they would. But I am going to do my part to
cooperate fully in this investigation. And I'm glad to do it.
Q In doing that part, did you have information about how it was that
Ms. Plame's job with the CIA became known --
MR. McCLELLAN: Let me go back. I really -- I appreciate that you're
asking these questions. I appreciate that you want to know this
information, as well. But there is an ongoing investigation right now.
We want to be as helpful as we can to those who are leading that
investigation. That includes me personally, as well. And so we need to
let that investigation proceed. If there's information that they feel
is helpful to share publicly, I'm sure that the people at the
Department of Justice would. But I'm just not going to answers those
questions from this podium. Those questions are best directed to the
Department of Justice, because I want to help them move forward in this
Q Scott, I have a follow-up on that. You said last year that you spoke
with the Vice President's Chief of Staff, Scooter Libby, and that he
was not the leaker, and he did not authorize the leak. Do you stand by
MR. McCLELLAN: Russell, we've addressed all these issues previously.
There's now an ongoing investigation. And I think if you've got
questions related to the investigation, I would suggest you direct
those questions to the Department of Justice. Like I said, if there's
information that they feel is helpful to share publicly, then I'm sure
that they will.
Q Second question: The Vice President took Supreme Court Justice Scalia
on a duck hunting trip to Louisiana while the Vice President had a case
pending before the Supreme Court. Does the President see this as
appropriate behavior, taking a Supreme Court Justice to a duck hunting
trip while he has a case pending? And does he believe that Justice
Scalia should recuse himself from that energy task force case?
MR. McCLELLAN: I think that you need to direct those questions to the
Vice President's office. I don't have -- I'm not --
Q I'm asking the President's view.
MR. McCLELLAN: -- I'm not familiar with the specifics.
Q Can I go to the major international story appearing all over the
globe? Pakistan now admits that Pakistani scientists are the source of
spreading nuclear knowledge to several countries. And, also, Musharraf
is blaming the United States for not providing him the proof. And
yesterday, at the Woodrow Wilson Center of Energy -- speaking and she
said that President Bush should stop now supporting dictatorships,
dictators in Pakistan, but stop supporting -- and she said that U.S.,
including President Bush was misled by Musharraf all along, including
today, on the spread of nuclear weapons or nuclear technology. Does
President believe now that he's satisfied with Musharraf's speeches or
what Musharraf told President Bush? Or do you think President will move
MR. McCLELLAN: We certainly value the assurances that President
Musharraf provided. I think I've already talked about this. But
proliferation is a very serious matter. It's a very high priority for
this administration. In a post-September 11th world it's important that
we do everything we can to stop proliferation of weapons of mass
destruction. That's why the President launched the proliferation
security initiative to work with other nations to interdict shipments
of weapons of mass destruction, and to stop the proliferation of
weapons of mass destruction. That's why the President is working
closely with other nations to stop proliferation of weapons of mass
And I think that if you look at some of the actions that have been
taken in Pakistan, it demonstrates that he is committed to the
assurances he provided us. The results are that a network has been
broken up, a network of proliferation has been broken up. There is
still ongoing investigation. We're still looking at a number of other
areas to continue to make sure we're doing everything to stop further
proliferation efforts. And we will continue to make this a high
priority. The President looks forward to talking more about this very
Q Scott, just one more --
MR. McCLELLAN: Sarah, go ahead.
Q The United States would like NATO to play a larger role in Iraq, but
the NATO Secretary General says Afghanistan must come first. Is this
going to cause a delay in turning Iraq back to the Iraqis?
MR. McCLELLAN: Is what going to cause a delay?
Q Well, doing Afghanistan -- taking care of Afghanistan first.
MR. McCLELLAN: First of all, we're continuing to move forward on the
transition of sovereignty to the Iraqi people, based on the time line
that was set out in the November 15th agreement. Obviously, NATO was
playing an important role in Afghanistan, and they have talked about
expanding that role. And we appreciate the efforts of NATO in
Afghanistan. The President met very recently with the U.N. Secretary
General, and they had a good discussion about Afghanistan. They also
had a good discussion about Iraq. And those are issues that we're
continuing to look at and continuing to discuss with NATO.
Q Is it possible the June 30th deadline could slide?
MR. McCLELLAN: Actually, I've addressed this issue, I think, over the
last few days or last week, at least. But we are working closely with
the Iraqi leaders and other Iraqis to move forward on the June 30th
time line for transferring sovereignty. It's important that we continue
to move forward in a timely manner to transfer sovereignty back to the
Iraqi people. They're assuming more and more responsibility for their
future. And we look forward to continuing to work with them to help
make -- help meet that time line.
Q What's he doing tomorrow, exactly?
MR. McCLELLAN: Well, he's going to be giving a speech on -- that will
focus on proliferation of weapons of mass destruction. Obviously, in a
MR. McCLELLAN: Here in D.C. Obviously in a post-September 11th world,
it is a high priority to confront the threat posed by weapons of mass
destruction. There are shadowy networks that exist that seek to spread
weapons of mass destruction. There are stateless regimes that seek to
acquire weapons of mass destruction. There are individuals who provide
technology and know-how to rogue states. And it's a very serious issue.
And that's why we have taken a number of steps to stop the
proliferation of weapons of mass destruction, through some of the
initiatives I mentioned earlier, as well as working individually with
different nations around the world.
Q Thank you.
MR. McCLELLAN: Thank you.
add a comment on this article
add a comment on this article