portland independent media center  
images audio video
newswire article portland metro

education | youth

Morrison Bridge Solidarity

Solidarity is definitely what we need. But we also need to communicate with each other before we're going to have solidarity.
First of all, let me make clear that I know a few of the people who marched onto the Morrison Bridge, and I admire them for their courage and dedication. I also was involved, as a student activist from Reed College, in the planning of the March 15 march, and I admire the people I met there just as much. I'll admit that I'm more sympathetic to the more mainstream side of the movement, and that I know more about it, but I do want to see more communication between both sides.

From this perspective, I want to try to address the issue of solidarity. I think that if we are ever going to make real change in this country and in Portland we're gonna need big-time solidarity. And I think that there is a real break down in solidarity in Portland. This includes a failure of the peace movement to adequately address the needs of oppressed people here at home, as well as a split between the radicals and the more mainstream activists in the peace movement. I think we all need to work very hard on this first break down in solidarity. I think the same is true for the radical/mainstream split, and I think that BOTH sides are responsible for making this happen. This means that mainstream activists need to condemn and act against illegitimate police violence in all its forms, no matter who is the target. It means that they should never apologize for this violence or blame the victims for the violence. It also means that when a joint labor/radical march is about to take direct action that the organizers know will bring about repression, that those organizers of the direct action inform EVERYONE in the march what they are about to get themselves into. We are all responsible for the predictable results of our actions. If I can predict that my actions will provoke the cops to attack a crowd which includes little kids, then maybe I will rethink my actions.

If we want real solidarity in Portland, the first step has to be opening up communication. I think it's important to remember that many in the crowd (me included) didn't even know what was happening on the Morrison Bridge. It's hard to see anything from below. More importantly, though, this action was not planned in coordination with the March 15th coalition, and so there was no way to organize some sort of solidarity on the part of the crowd. I think this shows that we need to talk to each other and go to each other's meetings so that we can begin to build real human ties. Neither side will be willing to put its ass on the line for the other until both recognize the hard work, honest dedication and courage of the other side.

I think that if we truly show a willingness to listen to each other, learn from each other, and work together, that we will be in a much better position to build a movement for lasting change in Portland.

The next planning meeting of the coalition that organized the March 15th rally is on Thursday, March 20th, at 6:30 pm
Friends Meeting House
4312 SE Stark

homepage: homepage: http://www.nwcampuspeace.org

Solidarity needed 16.Mar.2003 00:54

Anokpeace

We didn't plan on taking the bridge, our motive was to hault the traffic on the I-5, as you'll notice I was in the group that got pepper sprayed at the end of the freeway. We would of made it too if all the people on the bridge didn't hesitate.

And it wasn't organised previously, we can't do that and expect to surprise the police. We had enough solidarity within the bloc. The mainstream activists can march on streets pre-blocked off so they aren't heard. We however will not.

well 16.Mar.2003 07:42

margaret

I agree with you on a few points, that there does need to be a bit more solidarity with the mainstream activists and the radical activists. however, I have seen time and time again the radicals reach out the hand of sisterhood/brotherhood and have that hand crushed with the baseball bat some guy feels the need to carry around[what the hell? bloc kids dont even bring baseball bats]
The most inspiring part of the morrison bridge to me [besides of course where we almost got i-5] was how people, radicals and liberals alike, came up behind the bloc that got past the police and onto i-5. if they hadn't, we would have been stuck, cut off and arrested.
therefore, that solidarity was good, it worked.

although a lot of us will admit that it would have been good if someone had been able to be on the ground and let more people know what was going on [and therefore hopefully get more numbers on the bridge], i believe it went about as well as an unplanned action could have.

but the people who post to this site, bitter about the liberal peace movement, are people who have been physically or emotionally hurt by them. there are people in portland who are radical as all get out who provided important skills and media coverage to liberal peace actions in portland for months. for awhile indymedia was the only coverage that PPRC got.
then they turn around and denounce indymedia.
they tell KBOO not to announce the radical march of a month ago.

there does need to be solidarity, and we have been offering it time and time again.
slowly people are learning and realizing our hand has been out this entire time.
their organizations won't take solidarity with us, it threatens their status quo.
but individuals are realizing that we are their friends and are working for them and their children
and we are working hard and putting more on the line.

Beware 16.Mar.2003 09:00

Truth Sayer

Beware of the informants that go to the meetings. Portland PD has been approaching trendies for years paying them to go to 'activist' meetings...

Just an FYI.

Solidarity with whom? 16.Mar.2003 10:07

CW

With the cops? Because that's what you're asking when you inform the organizers of the cop-friendly liberal march about actions in advance. Peace cops run over to riot cops, and all rush in to block any really effective action. Those who want to be part of the solution know what the plans are. The rest are, rightfully, kept in the dark.

Hate to break it to you all... 16.Mar.2003 11:38

snoot

...but think about it for a minute. 30,000 showed up to this rally by the most conservative estimates. Having that many people show up to support the anti-war cause is *way* more important than whether you get your jollies by shutting down I-5 (which, by the way, is a cool idea). And then pointing fingers at the rest of these people and complaining that there's "no solidarity"?!! Wow, you *are* the reason that the peace movement has such difficulty. Civil disobedience can work, but you're never going to get there with any effectiveness unless you have at least the moral support of that 30K behind you. I've been on radical marches/rides and there is *always* this testosterone-inspired element that completely loses sight of why they're there in the first place. That only hurts our cause.

Reply 16.Mar.2003 12:13

Ira

First of all, I understand your concerns about discussing civil disobedience in advance. You're right that sharing that information is dangerous and that informants, etc are a real problem. However, I don't think this means that joint planning and communication is impossible. It's just that specific plans about CD have to be left vague.

With respect to Margaret's concerns, I want to first emphasize that the group which has organized the last few marches is NOT PPRC, but instead a coalition of organizations that includes PPRC and many others. Also, I know very little about pprc and I don't have personal experience with pprc taking action against radicals within pprc. However, I recognize that people within the mainstream are often more sympathetic to the police than to their victims. Your concerns are very serious, I can see, and it sounds like PPRC at least has very serious problems that it needs to address. However, beyond just ending it's antipathy towards civil disobedience, I'm curious to know what you think the mainstream coalition should do to take positive steps towards grasping your outstretched hand in solidarity?