Patriotic Shopping vs. Buy Nothing Day
George W. Bush wants us to shop. He says it?s our ?patriotic duty.? I hate to throw a wrench into the works, but next Thursday, November 23rd is my third favorite holiday of the year... It?s Buy Nothing Day, an annual revolt against consumer culture.
Patriotic Shopping vs. Buy Nothing Day
by Michael I. Niman, AlterNet, Nov 12, 2001 / ArtVoice Nov 14, 2001
George W. Bush wants us to shop. He says it?s our ?patriotic duty.? Shopping, he argues, like corporate tax cuts, helps with the ?War on Terrorism.? And what a great war it is. We can fulfill our patriot obligations in the aisles of Target, Sears and The Disney Store. Bin Laden Sucks. Buy a toaster. Buy a SUV. Your greed can save the world. Ain?t it great to be an American?
I hate to throw a wrench into the works, but next Thursday, November 23rd is my third favorite holiday of the year, after Halloween and World Car Free Day. It?s Buy Nothing Day, an annual revolt against consumer culture. What to do? What to do?
Ads You Never Saw
Buy nothing day falls every year on the day after Thanksgiving, the busiest shopping day of the year and the start of the annual Christmas shopping frenzy. The Buy Nothing Day TV ads tell us:
?...The average North American consumes five times more than a Mexican, ten times more than a Chinese person, and thirty times more than a person from India."
"We are the most voracious consumers in the world..."
"...a world which could die because of the way we North Americans live..."
"Give it a rest. November 23rd is Buy Nothing Day."
It?s a pretty good bet, however, you haven?t seen the ads. That?s because ABC, CBS and NBC all refused to sell time to air Buy Nothing Day ads. A spokesperson for General Electric?s NBC network brazenly told The Wall Street Journal that the ads were ?inimical to our legitimate business interests.? Their business interests include banking, weapons and nuclear power. The range of other potentially ?inimical? messages is limitless. Westinghouse?s CBS network explained that they censored the ads because they were "in opposition to the current economic policy in the United States." It wasn?t that long ago that a free press was a defining characteristic of America. I guess we can put that notion in the closet with the remnants of the New Deal and the Voter?s Rights Acts.
There?s a clear ecological component to Buy Nothing Day. We?re consuming the planet to death, depleting resources while throwing the ecosystem into chaos with global warming, ozone holes and toxic waste dumps. And it?s us. We?re the pigs crowding the rest of the world out of the feeding trough. And ironically, we?re selfishly at our worst at Christmas time when we vacuum up the bounty from the world?s sweatshops.
Working Them to Death
Along with cheap consumer goods, we also soak up much of the world?s animosity. Exploited laborers working in ?export zones? 12-hour days, 7 days a week for less than 20 cents an hour resent having their lives stolen. Their struggle for survival is desperate. Their health care is non-existent. Their work places are toxic. Their stories are well documented but we don?t seem to care. We are literally working them do death. Any argument you may care to believe about creating jobs for desperate people is nothing more than a self-serving stab at rationalization. The consumption gap between the rich nations and the poor nations continues to widen at alarming rates. Our consumption isn?t helping workers in poor countries any more than it?s fighting terrorism. In fact, it?s fueling the global inequalities that breed hate and terrorism.
Consumer culture is also poisoning our own society as the wealth gap between rich and poor Americans has been widening as well since the 1970s. At the top, conspicuous consumption among the wealthiest 20% of Americans has been rising for 20 years. The rest of us watch them on TV and engage in a grueling rat race to try to keep up with this virtual reference group. The results for working Americans have been catastrophic. The average family?s savings rate, according to Harvard Economist Juliet Schor, has decreased from 8% in 1980, to 4% in the early 1990s, to 0% today. High interest credit card debt, by comparison, has risen to an average of $7,000 per household. Bankruptcies have increased seven-fold in the past 20 years. The current call for more consumption in the face of massive layoffs will serve to increase these problems.
The increased spending has also meant increased work hours. American workers surpassed the Japanese in the mid 1990s to take the title for working the longest hours of any industrialized country ? with American workers putting in a full 6 weeks more of annual work than their German counterparts. Our endless needs have forced many families to put two adults into the workforce and to divert spending from charitable pursuits to personal consumption. We?ve repeatedly diverted money from social programs to personal spending through various tax cuts, poisoning the very fabric of society as tax-poor cities are forced to lay off teachers and firefighters by the score.
French sociologist Pierre Bourdieu argues that our consumption defines our class status, either allowing us entry into, or barring us from, circles of power. Juliet Schor takes Bourdieu?s theory one step further, arguing that consumerism maintains ?the basic structures of power and inequality that characterize our world.? The global problems we face today are the results of a world out of balance with haves and have-nots. Our orgy of consumption firmly places us among the haves. Shopping isn?t solving the world?s problems ? it?s exacerbating them.
I?ve laid the evils of conspicuous consumption out on the table. But let?s be real. We might take the 23rd off, but come the 24th most of you are gonna shop. We don?t have to choose, however, between no consumption and conspicuous consumption. It?s too easy to dismiss the ?no-consumption? option as unviable and retreat back into selfish consumerism. So let?s not force the issue. Instead, let?s embark on a third path ? responsible consumption.
Going out and buying a new gas guzzling SUV, as the White House and the automakers are admonishing us to do, is not patriotic. Such purchases lock us into an oil, and hence, war dependent future. Not smart. Ditto on the sweatshop crap. Your purchases fuel global inequality and undermine global stability. Be careful what brands you buy. Corporations often lobby in Washington against your interests. Be careful where you shop. Those big boxes often drive small community owned businesses out of business, then hire your neighbors at less than a living wage.
If you?re one of the lucky ones who can afford to shop, and you want to stimulate the economy, be sure to shop smart. Purchasing that Indonesian-made shirt from Wal Mart isn?t going to help the US economy. Wal Mart gets a fat cut, as does the branded corporation who contracted out to have the shirt made. The Wal Mart employees, however, will continue to get among America?s lowest wages. There?s no surging economic engine running here. I?m not, however, going to be elitist and tell you not to shop the big boxes for sweatshop goods. For many of us, our own exploited positions mandate we exploit others. What I am asking, is that you honestly evaluate whether or not you really need whatever piece of crap you are about to buy.
Get a Massage
If you don?t really need the big box?s trinkets, find some better more productive use for your shopping dollar. Buy locally produced goods and services that employ your neighbors at living wages while having a minimal impact on the environment. Spend your money this holiday season supporting musicians and artists. Go to clubs. Buy art. Patronize struggling inner-city businesses. Spend money at local restaurants and leave generous tips. Don?t buy an SUV ? instead spend the money to insulate your house. Buy a fuel-efficient hybrid car. Install a solar collector. Buy organic produce a farmer?s market. Visit an independent bookstore and buy a book. Buy used clothes. Have your house painted. Plant a tree. Donate to a Peace Center. Treat yourself to a professional massage or have an acupuncturist tune you up for the winter. You get the idea. Spend your money in a way that it will stimulate the local economy, not aggravate the global economy.
For more information about how to shop responsibly, see link to www.responsibleshopper.org.
Copyright 2001 Michael I. Niman. This article is syndicated by Alternet. For reprint info, contact www.alternet.org.
homepage: http://adbusters.org, http://www.responsibleshopper.org/
contribute to this article
contribute to this article
add comment to discussion